Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture?



 Science > Abortion > Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture?

LINK TO THIS PAGE  


rating :  0   |  0


  Page 1 of 1

1

 
Topic: Science > Abortion
User: "Tripping in Tempur Fields"
Date: 27 Jul 2004 09:19:30 PM
Object: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture?
In article <20040727163603.11452.00001621@mb-m23.aol.com>,
denisenoe@aol.com (Denise noe) wrote:

It's occurred to me that, despite all the controversy around it, today's

United

States might be a low abortion culture.
In the Victorian era, it was illegal but patent medicines were openly
advertised as "not to be taken by women in the family way." Of course

that was

their intended market.
Before the Iron Curtain fell, women in the Eastern Bloc nations used
abortion as the major method of birth control because contraceptives were so
undependable and hard to obtain.
Is the number of abortions in the modern US actually low

compared to that in

other countries and eras?

Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in her
lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!
As they say, we humans "need to need." When we have food, then we need
shelter, when we have shelter, we need security, when we have security we
need status, etc etc etc. When we have everything needed for survival and
more than any culture could imagine, we start obsessing over things like
boob size and interior decoration. There will never be any end to need.
The same principle operates for humanitarian causes; only when one
injustice is nearly squared away, the next one comes into clearer focus.
America in 2004 us a fairly humane society, there are no slaves, few
people are starving, people aren't being tortured, there are no lynch mobs
roaming the streets-- but it is not the job of the conscientious to be
content, we ask "what's next." As loathe as feminists would be to admit
it, it is this same milieu of for-the-most-part humanity that made both
the women's rights and fetal rights movements possible.
BTW, Denise, I thank you for your contributions to talk.abortion. You're
one of the few people who genuinely wants to provoke discussion and
transform the dialogue rather than just repeat the same hamfisted
arguments over and over again and change nobody's mind in the process.
Again, thanks.
=''' TWIDN € http://home.earthlink.net/~tagutcow
c oo email €

| \
- Investigative ~ Navigable ~ Vestigial ~ Fiduciary
.

User: "james g. keegan jr."

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 27 Jul 2004 09:39:35 PM
(Tripping in Tempur Fields) wrote in
news:tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com:

Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in
her lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!

do you apologize for lying when someone asks you to document a false claim
like the one you made here?
.
User: "Tripping in Tempur Fields"

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 27 Jul 2004 11:40:43 PM
In article <Xns9533E6820F42Fkeegannycaprrcom@130.133.1.4>, "james g.
keegan jr." <keegan@nycap.rr.com> wrote:

(Tripping in Tempur Fields) wrote in
news:tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com:

Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in
her lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!


do you apologize for lying when someone asks you to document a false claim
like the one you made here?

Supposing I could produce some online references, I would imagine it
would be you who would have to apologize for saying I was lying.
=====
http://www.libertarian.co.uk/lapubs/econn/econn011.pdf
Abortion is the main method of birth control in the Soviet
Union, with a working woman having an average of eight abortions
in a life time. The main reason for this is that there is no other
widely available form of contraception and a Soviet family has to
have two incomes. The woman is therefore forced to work by
economic circumstances.
intranet.westminster.org.uk/publications/elizabethan/magazine/2001/p23.htm
"In some countries, abortion is the most popular form of contraception;
in the former USSR, for example, the average woman has 6 to 7 abortions in
her lifetime, the mental and physical implications of which are
horrifying."
http://www.icddrb.org/pub/publication.jsp?classificationID=30&pubID=301
     "In the more eastern countries of Western Europe, such as Romania and
Bulgaria, the effective practice of withdrawal had never been widespread,
and abortion played the dominant role. In the former USSR­the first
country to permit legal abortion (in 1920)­up to 3 of 4 pregnancies were
being aborted, at least in Moscow."
http://www.cbctrust.com/abortion.html
Abortion has traditionally been the primary method of birth control in the
Soviet Union because of a lack of contraceptive devices and information,
and because of the traditional orientation of the Soviet health service
system towards termination, not prevention, of pregnancy. Officially, 55%
of known pregnancies are terminated by abortion, but the true rate is
probably higher.90 The level of induced abortion is higher in the former
USSR than in any other country in the world.91 It is not uncommon for a
Soviet woman to have four or five abortions and a few women to have as
many as twenty.
http://www.lib.utah.edu/epubs/undergrad/vol7/kotlyar.html
"Olga Lipovskaya, 35 years old, married three times, two children, and
seven abortions: "You stand in line before the door of the operating room,
seven or eight of you, waiting to be taken in. The clinic's staff is too
busy to do anything but operate, so as each woman who's finished staggers
out you take turns getting out of line for a few minutes, just to help her
get to the resting room down the hall. Then it's your turn, and you go
into a hall splattered with blood where two doctors are aborting seven or
eight women at the same time; they're usually very rough and rude,
shouting at you about keeping your legs wide open...if you're lucky they
give you a little sedative, mostly Valium. Then it's your turn to stagger
out to the resting room, where you're not allowed to spend more than two
hours because the production line, you see, is always very busy." Olga
estimates that she will have about fourteen abortions in total, which she
guesses to be the national average. She knows women who have had
twenty-five."
=======
Was I lying because the average Soviet woman had *more* than six
abortions? In any case, I hope you're able to defend your statement in
less time than it took to accuse *me* of lying.
=''' TWIDN € http://home.earthlink.net/~tagutcow
c oo email €

| \
- Investigative ~ Navigable ~ Vestigial ~ Fiduciary
.
User: "james g. keegan jr."

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 28 Jul 2004 03:18:40 PM
(Tripping in Tempur Fields) wrote in
news:tagutcow-2807040031370001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com:

In article <Xns9533E6820F42Fkeegannycaprrcom@130.133.1.4>, "james g.
keegan jr." <keegan@nycap.rr.com> wrote:

(Tripping in Tempur Fields) wrote in
news:tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com:

Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions
in her lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!


do you apologize for lying when someone asks you to document a false
claim like the one you made here?


Supposing I could produce some online references, I would imagine it
would be you who would have to apologize for saying I was lying.

if you could produce such rererences, why didn't you?
(i left the references you did provide below.)

=====

http://www.libertarian.co.uk/lapubs/econn/econn011.pdf

Abortion is the main method of birth control in the Soviet
Union, with a working woman having an average of eight abortions
in a life time. The main reason for this is that there is no other
widely available form of contraception and a Soviet family has to
have two incomes. The woman is therefore forced to work by
economic circumstances.


intranet.westminster.org.uk/publications/elizabethan/magazine/2001/p23.ht
m

"In some countries, abortion is the most popular form of contraception;
in the former USSR, for example, the average woman has 6 to 7 abortions
in her lifetime, the mental and physical implications of which are
horrifying."


http://www.icddrb.org/pub/publication.jsp?classificationID=30&pubID=301

     "In the more eastern countries of Western Europe, such as Romania
and Bulgaria, the effective practice of withdrawal had never been
widespread, and abortion played the dominant role. In the former
USSR­the first country to permit legal abortion (in 1920)­up to 3 of 4
pregnancies were being aborted, at least in Moscow."


http://www.cbctrust.com/abortion.html

Abortion has traditionally been the primary method of birth control in
the Soviet Union because of a lack of contraceptive devices and
information, and because of the traditional orientation of the Soviet
health service system towards termination, not prevention, of pregnancy.
Officially, 55% of known pregnancies are terminated by abortion, but the
true rate is probably higher.90 The level of induced abortion is higher
in the former USSR than in any other country in the world.91 It is not
uncommon for a Soviet woman to have four or five abortions and a few
women to have as many as twenty.


http://www.lib.utah.edu/epubs/undergrad/vol7/kotlyar.html

"Olga Lipovskaya, 35 years old, married three times, two children, and
seven abortions: "You stand in line before the door of the operating
room, seven or eight of you, waiting to be taken in. The clinic's staff
is too busy to do anything but operate, so as each woman who's finished
staggers out you take turns getting out of line for a few minutes, just
to help her get to the resting room down the hall. Then it's your turn,
and you go into a hall splattered with blood where two doctors are
aborting seven or eight women at the same time; they're usually very
rough and rude, shouting at you about keeping your legs wide open...if
you're lucky they give you a little sedative, mostly Valium. Then it's
your turn to stagger out to the resting room, where you're not allowed
to spend more than two hours because the production line, you see, is
always very busy." Olga estimates that she will have about fourteen
abortions in total, which she guesses to be the national average. She
knows women who have had twenty-five."

=======

Was I lying because the average Soviet woman had *more* than six
abortions? In any case, I hope you're able to defend your statement in
less time than it took to accuse *me* of lying.

=''' TWIDN € http://home.earthlink.net/~tagutcow
c oo email €


| \
- Investigative ~ Navigable ~ Vestigial ~ Fiduciary

.


User: "John Savard"

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 28 Jul 2004 12:44:24 AM
On 28 Jul 2004 02:39:35 GMT, "james g. keegan jr." <keegan@nycap.rr.com> wrote,
in part:

tagutcow@earthlink.net (Tripping in Tempur Fields) wrote in
news:tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com:

Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in
her lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!

do you apologize for lying when someone asks you to document a false claim
like the one you made here?

The book "Moscow Farewell" might prove interesting.
John Savard
http://home.ecn.ab.ca/~jsavard/index.html
.
User: "james g. keegan jr."

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 28 Jul 2004 03:19:18 PM
jsavard@excxn.aNOSPAMb.cdn.invalid (John Savard) wrote in
news:41073d1f.849417@news.ecn.ab.ca:

On 28 Jul 2004 02:39:35 GMT, "james g. keegan jr." <keegan@nycap.rr.com>
wrote, in part:

tagutcow@earthlink.net (Tripping in Tempur Fields) wrote in
news:tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com:


Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in
her lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!


do you apologize for lying when someone asks you to document a false
claim like the one you made here?


The book "Moscow Farewell" might prove interesting.

i'm familiar with it.
.



User: "David W. Barnes"

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 27 Jul 2004 09:29:41 PM
In article
<tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com>, Tripping
in Tempur Fields <tagutcow@earthlink.net> wrote:

In article <20040727163603.11452.00001621@mb-m23.aol.com>,
denisenoe@aol.com (Denise noe) wrote:

It's occurred to me that, despite all the controversy around it, today's

United

States might be a low abortion culture.
In the Victorian era, it was illegal but patent medicines were openly
advertised as "not to be taken by women in the family way." Of course

that was

their intended market.
Before the Iron Curtain fell, women in the Eastern Bloc nations used
abortion as the major method of birth control because contraceptives were so
undependable and hard to obtain.
Is the number of abortions in the modern US actually low

compared to that in

other countries and eras?


Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in her
lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!

Prove your claim.
.
User: "Ray Fischer"

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 27 Jul 2004 11:45:04 PM
David W. Barnes <DumpBushInNovember@usa.com> wrote:

<tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com>, Tripping

Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in her
lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!


Prove your claim.

The rate of abortions in the USSR was indeed really high. While there
are about 22 abortions for every 100 births in the USA, in the USSR
there were as many as 300 abortions per 100 live births. Now it's
down to about 160 per 100 births.
--
Ray Fischer
rfischer@sonic.net
.

User: "Paul Anderson"

Title: Re: Do we live in a low abortion culture? 27 Jul 2004 10:19:25 PM
On Tue, 27 Jul 2004 19:29:41 -0700, "David W. Barnes"
<DumpBushInNovember@usa.com> wrote:

In article
<tagutcow-2707042210250001@user-0c992qm.cable.mindspring.com>, Tripping
in Tempur Fields <tagutcow@earthlink.net> wrote:

In article <20040727163603.11452.00001621@mb-m23.aol.com>,
denisenoe@aol.com (Denise noe) wrote:

It's occurred to me that, despite all the controversy around it, today's
United States might be a low abortion culture.

It is not.
....

Well the average woman in the USSR had an average of six abortions in her
lifetime. Boy howdy, those women sure were liberated!


Prove your claim.

Which part, the number of abortions or the "liberated" *****?
The number of abortions are on a par with the US in the late 19th -
early 20th centuries -- due to a lack of availablity and acceptablity
of contraception and a repression of sexuality.
The Pro-Lifers bewail and bemoan teenage sexuality and the abortion
rate but will *NOT* accept what has been proven to cut both:
http://www.independent-media.tv/item.cfm?fmedia_id=8084&fcategory_desc=Under%20Reported
"The Netherlands/Holland has the lowest abortion rate in the world,
about 6 abortions per 1000 women per year. Contraception and abortion
is legal and freely available, covered by the national health
insurance plan. Holland conducts extensive public education on
contraception, family planning, and sexuality. An ethic of personal
responsibility for one's sexual activity is strongly promoted.
Dutch teenagers start having sex at an older age and have less
frequent sex, than American teenagers. The Dutch teenage pregnancy
rate is 9 times lower than in the U.S."
.



  Page 1 of 1

1

 


Related Articles
The Vast Left-Wing Culture Of Death
Re: How could anyone not Jewish in their right mind not become anti-Semitic when reading the posts on soc.culture.jewish.moderated
***** Culture and its War on Christian Moral Values
Duke Cunningham Bribery Case Spills Over to... TOM DELAY (GOP, The Culture of Corruption)
Re: SOC.CULTURE.ISRAEL.MODERATED
Culture war prospects in decency battle looking up for 2008
No Post-Imus Culture for Catholic Bashers
Re: SOC.CULTURE.ISRAEL.MODERATED
Re: 50 MIllion Abortions in the US = The End of Your Nation, Your Culture, and Your Life. Margaret Sanger, Filthy Subhuman Jew Devil, Founder of 'Planned Parenthood' and the Jews Who Perpetuate the Baby Body Parts industry. THESE PEOPLE NEED TO BE SM
Tony Blair blames spate of murders on black culture
The culture of lies
Bush Family Planning Appointee Called Contraceptives Part Of The ŚCulture Of Deathą
Re: Judeo-Christian Culture Permissive and Criminal Sexually
Re: STOP CROSS-POSTING TO SOC.CULTURE.IRANIAN THIS IRELLEVANT ***** YOU FUCKING DIM WIT *****
Bush Calls for Pro-Life Culture at Catholic Prayer
 

NEWER

pg.716     pg.544     pg.412     pg.311     pg.234     pg.175     pg.130     pg.96     pg.70     pg.50     pg.35     pg.24     pg.16     pg.10     pg.6     pg.3     pg.1

OLDER