Role of Language in Politics



 Science > Abortion > Role of Language in Politics

LINK TO THIS PAGE  


rating :  0   |  0


  Page 1 of 1

1

 
Topic: Science > Abortion
User: "Papa Jack"
Date: 06 May 2004 10:27:09 AM
Object: Role of Language in Politics
On May 6, 2004, The Stanford Daily posted an artiThey also described
President George W. Bush's rhetorical techniques for garnering support
for the war in Iraq.
cle by
Andrew Gay titled: "Profs Explain Role of Language in
Politics." Go to:
http://daily.stanford.edu/tempo?page=content&id=14098&repository=0001_article
_____________________________________________________________________________
Excerpts:
"Last night, two well-known linguists, Deborah
Tannen and Geoffrey Nunberg, discussed the lan-
guage of American politics and how it shapes
political debate. In particular, they empha-
sized the polarization of political discussion
and the tendency to view politics as conflict-
driven....
[...]
"Tannen also discussed how language relates to
other topics, such as abortion.
"'The fact that abortion-rights supporters do not
use the word [abortion] is because the pro-life
movement has been so successful in making
‘abortion' a bad word,' she said. 'The very con-
cept of abortion now is associated with the image
of partial-birth abortions. That use of the word
confirms the image people have of a baby ready to
be born but killed instead.'
"Tannen also pointed out that in framing the argu-
ment as between pro-choice and pro-life factions,
the opponents of abortion have been successful in
winning the battle of language.
"'The words pro-choice imply that there is a choice,
that it is something frivolous,' she said. 'By
refusing to use the word abortion, they continue
the stigma of abortions as a negative thing. Also,
pro-life is excellent language because no one wants
to be pro-death."
[...]
____________________________________________________________________________
Papa Jack comments:
The Culture of Death still believe they win the hearts
of women when they insist on using euphemisms like
"Choice." They have a hissy over the term partial-birth
abortion -- insisting on calling the procedure "Intact
D&E" (dilate and extract).
The fact is that the general public isn't nearly as
stupid as the Pro-Aborts like to believe. Most under-
stand that "Choice" really means abortion -- and abor-
tion really means the killing of an unborn child.
But, as we've discussed before, a substantial percentage
of Pro-Aborts are "hardwired," i.e., unable to consider
various alternatives before choosing a plan of action.
Most just repeat the same "bumper sticker" slogans they
learned years ago, and refuse to grow in their under-
standing of the issues.
Thanks for considering my point of view.
.

User: "Patrick Gaines"

Title: Re: Role of Language in Politics 06 May 2004 04:46:05 PM
(Papa Jack) wrote in message news:<6f9e1b49.0405060727.5e212c87@posting.google.com>...

On May 6, 2004, The Stanford Daily posted an artiThey also described
President George W. Bush's rhetorical techniques for garnering support
for the war in Iraq.
cle by
Andrew Gay titled: "Profs Explain Role of Language in
Politics." Go to:

http://daily.stanford.edu/tempo?page=content&id=14098&repository=0001_article
_____________________________________________________________________________
Excerpts:

"Last night, two well-known linguists, Deborah
Tannen and Geoffrey Nunberg, discussed the lan-
guage of American politics and how it shapes
political debate. In particular, they empha-
sized the polarization of political discussion
and the tendency to view politics as conflict-
driven....
[...]

"Tannen also discussed how language relates to
other topics, such as abortion.

"'The fact that abortion-rights supporters do not
use the word [abortion] is because the pro-life
movement has been so successful in making
?abortion' a bad word,' she said. 'The very con-
cept of abortion now is associated with the image
of partial-birth abortions. That use of the word
confirms the image people have of a baby ready to
be born but killed instead.'

"Tannen also pointed out that in framing the argu-
ment as between pro-choice and pro-life factions,
the opponents of abortion have been successful in
winning the battle of language.

"'The words pro-choice imply that there is a choice,
that it is something frivolous,' she said. 'By
refusing to use the word abortion, they continue
the stigma of abortions as a negative thing. Also,
pro-life is excellent language because no one wants
to be pro-death."
[...]
____________________________________________________________________________

Papa Jack comments:
The Culture of Death still believe they win the hearts
of women when they insist on using euphemisms like
"Choice." They have a hissy over the term partial-birth
abortion -- insisting on calling the procedure "Intact
D&E" (dilate and extract).

The fact is that the general public isn't nearly as
stupid as the Pro-Aborts like to believe. Most under-
stand that "Choice" really means abortion -- and abor-
tion really means the killing of an unborn child.

But, as we've discussed before, a substantial percentage
of Pro-Aborts are "hardwired," i.e., unable to consider
various alternatives before choosing a plan of action.
Most just repeat the same "bumper sticker" slogans they
learned years ago, and refuse to grow in their under-
standing of the issues.

Thanks for considering my point of view.

Exactly what I was thinking, but you said it better than I would have done. Kudos.
.

User: "Ray Fischer"

Title: Re: Role of Language in Politics 07 May 2004 11:41:12 AM
Papa Jackass <papajack@stic.net> wrote:

On May 6, 2004, The Stanford Daily posted an artiThey also described
President George W. Bush's rhetorical techniques for garnering support
for the war in Iraq.
http://daily.stanford.edu/tempo?page=content&id=14098&repository=0001_article
_____________________________________________________________________________
Excerpts:

"Last night, two well-known linguists, Deborah
Tannen and Geoffrey Nunberg, discussed the lan-
guage of American politics and how it shapes
political debate. In particular, they empha-
sized the polarization of political discussion
and the tendency to view politics as conflict-
driven....
[...]
____________________________________________________________________________

The Culture of Death

What a sleazy hypcorite Jackass is.
--
Ray Fischer
rfischer@sonic.net
.


  Page 1 of 1

1

 


Related Articles
Re: Language in Politics
Church is playing politics
ScottyFLL@aussiemail.com.au/ScottyFLLForger: Goatblowing Jizqueenof alt.politics.homosexuality
Science Casualty of Fundamentalist Politics
POLITICS PUT OVER WOMEN AND CHILDREN'S HEALTH
Re: alt.politics.democrats.d,alt.politics.usa.republican
Unreliable abortion information published because of politics
Sexual Politics And Scientific Logic: The Issue Of Homosexuality
Bush's 'Elmer Gantry' Politics
Re: Why democracy overcomes radical politics
Michael Moore- A Communist? You all Decide + Politics of Other "Bush Bashers" such as Whoopi Goldberg and Al Franken
Voters disgusted with the politics game being played by the Democrats
New Politics of President-Hating
Reality - screw the politics
ScottyFLL@aussiemail.com.au/ScottyFLLForger: Goatblowing Jizqueenof alt.politics.homosexuality
 

NEWER

pg.716     pg.544     pg.412     pg.311     pg.234     pg.175     pg.130     pg.96     pg.70     pg.50     pg.35     pg.24     pg.16     pg.10     pg.6     pg.3     pg.1

OLDER