Religions > Atheism > A conservative Christian opposing public prayer at football games! (Buddhist ones, that is)
| Topic: |
Religions > Atheism |
| User: |
"turk" |
| Date: |
04 Sep 2006 04:07:00 PM |
| Object: |
A conservative Christian opposing public prayer at football games! (Buddhist ones, that is) |
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2006/09/even_wingnuts_respond_to_cultu.php
Category: Religion
Posted on: September 3, 2006 12:15 PM, by PZ Myers
Wow, I'm impressed: The J Train finds a small guttering flicker of reason on
WingNutDaily. It's an article by a conservative Christian opposing public
prayer at football games-he'd been in Hawai'i, where he'd been shocked to
discover that pre-game prayers were given by Buddhist monks, and he found
himself an uncomfortable minority in a sea of people following some strange
religion (hmmm.does anybody else know what that's like?)
It's actually funny to read. He's plainly horrified that he'd have to be in
the presence of someone reciting a pagan prayer! He doesn't quite get the
response right, though.
We were frozen in shock and incredulity! What to do? To continue to stand
and observe this prayer would represent a betrayal of our own faith and
imply the honoring of a pagan deity that was anathema to our beliefs. To sit
would be an act of extreme rudeness and disrespect in the eyes of our
Japanese hosts and neighbors, who value above all other things deference and
respect in their social interactions. I am sorry to say that in the
confusion of the moment we chose the easier path and elected to continue to
stand in silence so as not to create a scene or ill will among those who
were seated nearby.
As I thought through the incident over the next few days I supposed that
the duty of offering the pre-game prayer rotated through the local clergy
and we just happened to arrive on the night that the responsibility fell to
the Buddhist priest. However, after inquiring I learned that due to the
predominance of Buddhist and Shinto adherents in this town, it was the
normal practice to have a member of one these faiths offer the pre-game
prayer, and Christian clergy were never included. Needless to say that was
our first and last football game. Although many of the students we worked
with continued to invite us to the games, we were forced to decline. We knew
that if we were to attend again we would be forced to abstain from the
pre-game activity. And not wanting to offend our Asiatic neighbors and
colleagues, we simply refrained from attending.
Well.so his solution was to simply and completely withdraw from the social
activity? I wonder how he'd react if the entire culture was saturated with
overt displays of such religiosity-where courtrooms would claim their
justice was founded on their religion, where the government, top to bottom,
was loaded with official who would regularly trumpet their religious
affiliation, where store owners would declare themselves adherents of
particular faiths, and promise that a percentage of their profits would go
to promote their beliefs, where much of the business of the town was
mediated via contacts at places of worship? Would he divorce himself from
the culture entirely, throw out his radio and TV, bunker down in his house
and pray?
At least he appreciates part of the experience.
I would say in love to my Christian brothers and sisters, before you yearn
for the imposition of prayer and similar rituals in your public schools, you
might consider attending a football game at Wahiawa High School. Because
unless you're ready to endure the unwilling exposure of yourself and your
children to those beliefs and practices that your own faith forswears, you
have no right to insist that others sit in silence and complicity while you
do the same to them. I, for one, slept better at night knowing that because
Judeo-Christian prayers were not being offered at my children's schools, I
didn't have to worry about them being confronted with Buddhist, Shinto,
Wiccan, Satanic or any other prayer ritual I might find offensive.
Diversity of ideas is bad, I guess. I think I've got a new notion to keep
the quality of my university's students high, though: if the presence of
this godless atheist on the faculty doesn't scare the fanatics away, I just
have to mention that our university events, such as the opening convocation
of classes last week, often include a Native American blessing. Drums,
chanting, the whole works.
I handle them the same way I do the Christian hymns we often get at the
Christmas concert: sit quietly, enjoy the music if not the superstition, and
take it as a positive aspect of the culture I live in.
.
|
|
| User: "Denis Loubet" |
|
| Title: Re: A conservative Christian opposing public prayer at football games! (Buddhist ones, that is) |
04 Sep 2006 07:21:23 PM |
|
|
"turk" <turk96@nowaynohow.not> wrote in message
news:-s6dnUZfp6jqCGHZnZ2dnUVZ_v-dnZ2d@comcast.com...
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2006/09/even_wingnuts_respond_to_cultu.php
Category: Religion
Posted on: September 3, 2006 12:15 PM, by PZ Myers
Wow, I'm impressed: The J Train finds a small guttering flicker of reason
on WingNutDaily. It's an article by a conservative Christian opposing
public prayer at football games-he'd been in Hawai'i, where he'd been
shocked to discover that pre-game prayers were given by Buddhist monks,
and he found himself an uncomfortable minority in a sea of people
following some strange religion (hmmm.does anybody else know what that's
like?)
It's actually funny to read. He's plainly horrified that he'd have to be
in the presence of someone reciting a pagan prayer! He doesn't quite get
the response right, though.
We were frozen in shock and incredulity! What to do? To continue to stand
and observe this prayer would represent a betrayal of our own faith and
imply the honoring of a pagan deity that was anathema to our beliefs. To
sit would be an act of extreme rudeness and disrespect in the eyes of our
Japanese hosts and neighbors, who value above all other things deference
and respect in their social interactions. I am sorry to say that in the
confusion of the moment we chose the easier path and elected to continue
to stand in silence so as not to create a scene or ill will among those
who were seated nearby.
You're right! This is absolutely priceless! :-)
I want to get in that guy's face and shout "How do you fuckin' like it,
*****?"
As I thought through the incident over the next few days I supposed that
the duty of offering the pre-game prayer rotated through the local clergy
and we just happened to arrive on the night that the responsibility fell
to the Buddhist priest. However, after inquiring I learned that due to the
predominance of Buddhist and Shinto adherents in this town, it was the
normal practice to have a member of one these faiths offer the pre-game
prayer, and Christian clergy were never included. Needless to say that was
our first and last football game.
"How do you fuckin' like it, *****?"
Although many of the students we worked with continued to invite us to the
games, we were forced to decline. We knew that if we were to attend again
we would be forced to abstain from the pre-game activity. And not wanting
to offend our Asiatic neighbors and colleagues, we simply refrained from
attending.
"How do you fuckin' like it, *****?"
Well.so his solution was to simply and completely withdraw from the social
activity? I wonder how he'd react if the entire culture was saturated with
overt displays of such religiosity-where courtrooms would claim their
justice was founded on their religion, where the government, top to
bottom, was loaded with official who would regularly trumpet their
religious affiliation, where store owners would declare themselves
adherents of particular faiths, and promise that a percentage of their
profits would go to promote their beliefs, where much of the business of
the town was mediated via contacts at places of worship?
I don't think the ***** would like it at all.
Would he divorce himself from the culture entirely, throw out his radio
and TV, bunker down in his house and pray?
At least he appreciates part of the experience.
I would say in love to my Christian brothers and sisters, before you
yearn for the imposition of prayer and similar rituals in your public
schools, you might consider attending a football game at Wahiawa High
School. Because unless you're ready to endure the unwilling exposure of
yourself and your children to those beliefs and practices that your own
faith forswears, you have no right to insist that others sit in silence
and complicity while you do the same to them. I, for one, slept better at
night knowing that because Judeo-Christian prayers were not being offered
at my children's schools, I didn't have to worry about them being
confronted with Buddhist, Shinto, Wiccan, Satanic or any other prayer
ritual I might find offensive.
The problem with this post is I can't tell who's talking. Is the above
paragraph from the ***** who maybe learned something, or is it turk
pointing out the facts.
Diversity of ideas is bad, I guess. I think I've got a new notion to keep
the quality of my university's students high, though: if the presence of
this godless atheist on the faculty doesn't scare the fanatics away, I
just have to mention that our university events, such as the opening
convocation of classes last week, often include a Native American
blessing. Drums, chanting, the whole works.
That's cool!
I handle them the same way I do the Christian hymns we often get at the
Christmas concert: sit quietly, enjoy the music if not the superstition,
and take it as a positive aspect of the culture I live in.
That can work.
--
Denis Loubet
dloubet@io.com
http://www.io.com/~dloubet
http://www.ashenempires.com
.
|
|
|
| User: "turk" |
|
| Title: Re: A conservative Christian opposing public prayer at football games! (Buddhist ones, that is) |
04 Sep 2006 08:06:38 PM |
|
|
"Denis Loubet" <dloubet@io.com> wrote in message
news:wNadnfbbNLefXmHZnZ2dnUVZ_u-dnZ2d@io.com...
"turk" <turk96@nowaynohow.not> wrote in message
news:-s6dnUZfp6jqCGHZnZ2dnUVZ_v-dnZ2d@comcast.com...
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2006/09/even_wingnuts_respond_to_cultu.php
Category: Religion
Posted on: September 3, 2006 12:15 PM, by PZ Myers
Wow, I'm impressed: The J Train finds a small guttering flicker of reason
on WingNutDaily. It's an article by a conservative Christian opposing
public prayer at football games-he'd been in Hawai'i, where he'd been
shocked to discover that pre-game prayers were given by Buddhist monks,
and he found himself an uncomfortable minority in a sea of people
following some strange religion (hmmm.does anybody else know what that's
like?)
It's actually funny to read. He's plainly horrified that he'd have to be
in the presence of someone reciting a pagan prayer! He doesn't quite get
the response right, though.
We were frozen in shock and incredulity! What to do? To continue to
stand and observe this prayer would represent a betrayal of our own faith
and imply the honoring of a pagan deity that was anathema to our beliefs.
To sit would be an act of extreme rudeness and disrespect in the eyes of
our Japanese hosts and neighbors, who value above all other things
deference and respect in their social interactions. I am sorry to say
that in the confusion of the moment we chose the easier path and elected
to continue to stand in silence so as not to create a scene or ill will
among those who were seated nearby.
You're right! This is absolutely priceless! :-)
I want to get in that guy's face and shout "How do you fuckin' like it,
*****?"
As I thought through the incident over the next few days I supposed that
the duty of offering the pre-game prayer rotated through the local clergy
and we just happened to arrive on the night that the responsibility fell
to the Buddhist priest. However, after inquiring I learned that due to
the predominance of Buddhist and Shinto adherents in this town, it was
the normal practice to have a member of one these faiths offer the
pre-game prayer, and Christian clergy were never included. Needless to
say that was our first and last football game.
"How do you fuckin' like it, *****?"
Although many of the students we worked with continued to invite us to
the games, we were forced to decline. We knew that if we were to attend
again we would be forced to abstain from the pre-game activity. And not
wanting to offend our Asiatic neighbors and colleagues, we simply
refrained from attending.
"How do you fuckin' like it, *****?"
Well.so his solution was to simply and completely withdraw from the
social activity? I wonder how he'd react if the entire culture was
saturated with overt displays of such religiosity-where courtrooms would
claim their justice was founded on their religion, where the government,
top to bottom, was loaded with official who would regularly trumpet their
religious affiliation, where store owners would declare themselves
adherents of particular faiths, and promise that a percentage of their
profits would go to promote their beliefs, where much of the business of
the town was mediated via contacts at places of worship?
I don't think the ***** would like it at all.
Would he divorce himself from the culture entirely, throw out his radio
and TV, bunker down in his house and pray?
At least he appreciates part of the experience.
I would say in love to my Christian brothers and sisters, before you
yearn for the imposition of prayer and similar rituals in your public
schools, you might consider attending a football game at Wahiawa High
School. Because unless you're ready to endure the unwilling exposure of
yourself and your children to those beliefs and practices that your own
faith forswears, you have no right to insist that others sit in silence
and complicity while you do the same to them. I, for one, slept better at
night knowing that because Judeo-Christian prayers were not being offered
at my children's schools, I didn't have to worry about them being
confronted with Buddhist, Shinto, Wiccan, Satanic or any other prayer
ritual I might find offensive.
The problem with this post is I can't tell who's talking. Is the above
paragraph from the ***** who maybe learned something, or is it turk
pointing out the facts.
The paragraphs that start with an indent are those of the original letter
writers. The critique by the author is the rest. I didn't write it, I just
cut and pasted this one. It's easier to make out if you go to the link.
turk
--
"The point now is how do we work together to achieve important goals. And
one such goal is a democracy in Germany." -George W. Bush, D.C., May 5, 2006
.
|
|
|
| User: "Denis Loubet" |
|
| Title: Re: A conservative Christian opposing public prayer at football games! (Buddhist ones, that is) |
04 Sep 2006 10:26:08 PM |
|
|
"turk" <turk96@nowaynohow.not> wrote in message
news:-PmdndobPM4HUGHZnZ2dnUVZ_vmdnZ2d@comcast.com...
"Denis Loubet" <dloubet@io.com> wrote in message
news:wNadnfbbNLefXmHZnZ2dnUVZ_u-dnZ2d@io.com...
"turk" <turk96@nowaynohow.not> wrote in message
news:-s6dnUZfp6jqCGHZnZ2dnUVZ_v-dnZ2d@comcast.com...
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2006/09/even_wingnuts_respond_to_cultu.php
Category: Religion
Posted on: September 3, 2006 12:15 PM, by PZ Myers
Wow, I'm impressed: The J Train finds a small guttering flicker of
reason on WingNutDaily. It's an article by a conservative Christian
opposing public prayer at football games-he'd been in Hawai'i, where
he'd been shocked to discover that pre-game prayers were given by
Buddhist monks, and he found himself an uncomfortable minority in a sea
of people following some strange religion (hmmm.does anybody else know
what that's like?)
It's actually funny to read. He's plainly horrified that he'd have to be
in the presence of someone reciting a pagan prayer! He doesn't quite get
the response right, though.
We were frozen in shock and incredulity! What to do? To continue to
stand and observe this prayer would represent a betrayal of our own
faith and imply the honoring of a pagan deity that was anathema to our
beliefs. To sit would be an act of extreme rudeness and disrespect in
the eyes of our Japanese hosts and neighbors, who value above all other
things deference and respect in their social interactions. I am sorry to
say that in the confusion of the moment we chose the easier path and
elected to continue to stand in silence so as not to create a scene or
ill will among those who were seated nearby.
You're right! This is absolutely priceless! :-)
I want to get in that guy's face and shout "How do you fuckin' like it,
*****?"
As I thought through the incident over the next few days I supposed
that the duty of offering the pre-game prayer rotated through the local
clergy and we just happened to arrive on the night that the
responsibility fell to the Buddhist priest. However, after inquiring I
learned that due to the predominance of Buddhist and Shinto adherents in
this town, it was the normal practice to have a member of one these
faiths offer the pre-game prayer, and Christian clergy were never
included. Needless to say that was our first and last football game.
"How do you fuckin' like it, *****?"
Although many of the students we worked with continued to invite us to
the games, we were forced to decline. We knew that if we were to attend
again we would be forced to abstain from the pre-game activity. And not
wanting to offend our Asiatic neighbors and colleagues, we simply
refrained from attending.
"How do you fuckin' like it, *****?"
Well.so his solution was to simply and completely withdraw from the
social activity? I wonder how he'd react if the entire culture was
saturated with overt displays of such religiosity-where courtrooms would
claim their justice was founded on their religion, where the government,
top to bottom, was loaded with official who would regularly trumpet
their religious affiliation, where store owners would declare themselves
adherents of particular faiths, and promise that a percentage of their
profits would go to promote their beliefs, where much of the business of
the town was mediated via contacts at places of worship?
I don't think the ***** would like it at all.
Would he divorce himself from the culture entirely, throw out his radio
and TV, bunker down in his house and pray?
At least he appreciates part of the experience.
I would say in love to my Christian brothers and sisters, before you
yearn for the imposition of prayer and similar rituals in your public
schools, you might consider attending a football game at Wahiawa High
School. Because unless you're ready to endure the unwilling exposure of
yourself and your children to those beliefs and practices that your own
faith forswears, you have no right to insist that others sit in silence
and complicity while you do the same to them. I, for one, slept better
at night knowing that because Judeo-Christian prayers were not being
offered at my children's schools, I didn't have to worry about them
being confronted with Buddhist, Shinto, Wiccan, Satanic or any other
prayer ritual I might find offensive.
The problem with this post is I can't tell who's talking. Is the above
paragraph from the ***** who maybe learned something, or is it turk
pointing out the facts.
The paragraphs that start with an indent are those of the original letter
writers. The critique by the author is the rest. I didn't write it, I
just cut and pasted this one. It's easier to make out if you go to the
link.
I'll try that, thanks! :-)
--
Denis Loubet
dloubet@io.com
http://www.io.com/~dloubet
http://www.ashenempires.com
.
|
|
|
|
|
|

|
Related Articles |
|
|