Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE !



 Religions > Atheism > Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE !

LINK TO THIS PAGE  


rating :  0   |  0


  Page 1 of 1

1

 
Topic: Religions > Atheism
User: "juliekale"
Date: 12 Aug 2003 06:39:04 PM
Object: Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE !
"Kix Adams" <okkix@juno.com> wrote in message
news:6ee1b361.0308120920.1fc8148a@posting.google.com...

hunter77099@yahoo.com (Truth Hunter) wrote in message

news:<e164e783.0308101615.5a3d9f84@posting.google.com>...

God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE !



Read your Bible!


I've not only read it, but studied it, and teach it.

Does this make sense:
God takes his only son and lets him be crucified meaning to be killed
on the cross because of Adam and Eve eat one rotten APPLE?


It wasn't an apple. It was the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good
and evil. Meaning they chose for all mankind to know the difference
between good and evil and to have the freedom to make the choice
between living good, moral, Godly life and choosing a life of evil.

It's so very interesting to me that in the bible you see so many examples of
children paying for the sins of their parents, despite the fact that this is
supposed to be something god finds unjust and unreasonable.
You're talking about one mistake made by two ignorant people who were not
told that their actions would cause such great harm to humanity, and yet
your loving god has chosen to punish the whole of humanity for something we
had nothing to do with.

Jesus's death doesn't change that.


No, Jesus's death does not change the fact that we each have a choice.
But it insures that those who accept what he offers will be forgiven
for their evil doings.

Why should I seek forgivness when I had no part in creating my own sinful
nature?

I'm still a moral agent who should accept personal responsibility for my

actions.


And you will, as will all of us. That's why it's so important to have
the redemption promised to us by Jesus.

Without it, we go from god's frying pan into his fire.
--
Be as you are.
From alt.atheism only...Julie Kale (aa 1029)
www.juliekale.com
.

User: "bam"

Title: Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE ! 12 Aug 2003 07:06:49 PM
"juliekale" <me[spammenot]@juliekale.com> wrote

It's so very interesting to me that in the bible you see so many examples

of

children paying for the sins of their parents, despite the fact that this

is

supposed to be something god finds unjust and unreasonable.
You're talking about one mistake made by two ignorant people who were not
told that their actions would cause such great harm to humanity, and yet
your loving god has chosen to punish the whole of humanity for something

we

had nothing to do with.

You had nothing to do with your existence, or your chance for eternal
happiness either. This life's a drop in the bucket. So get back in the race.
BAM
.
User: "Barry OGrady"

Title: Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE ! 15 Aug 2003 09:29:09 AM
On Tue, 12 Aug 2003 20:06:49 -0400, "bam" <mcca5761@bellsouthblahblah.net> wrote:


"juliekale" <me[spammenot]@juliekale.com> wrote

It's so very interesting to me that in the bible you see so many examples

of

children paying for the sins of their parents, despite the fact that this
is supposed to be something god finds unjust and unreasonable.
You're talking about one mistake made by two ignorant people who were not
told that their actions would cause such great harm to humanity, and yet
your loving god has chosen to punish the whole of humanity for something
we had nothing to do with.


You had nothing to do with your existence, or your chance for eternal
happiness either. This life's a drop in the bucket. So get back in the race.

This drop in the bucket is all we get, so it's worth fighting for.

BAM

-Barry
========
Web page: http://members.optusnet.com.au/~barry.og
Atheist, radio scanner, LIPD information.
Voicemail/fax number +14136227640
.


User: "ArmsTom"

Title: Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE ! 16 Aug 2003 07:16:38 PM
"juliekale" <me[spammenot]@juliekale.com> wrote in
news:I1N_a.41059$K4.2002328@twister.tampabay.rr.com:

"Kix Adams" <okkix@juno.com> wrote in message
news:6ee1b361.0308132359.6a399d64@posting.google.com...

"juliekale" <me[spammenot]@juliekale.com> wrote in message

news:<sUe_a.30684$qg3.2040176@twister.tampabay.rr.com>...


It's so very interesting to me that in the bible you see so many

examples of

children paying for the sins of their parents, despite the fact
that

this is

supposed to be something god finds unjust and unreasonable.


Could you give me an example of what you're talking about? Because
I'm not real clear on what you mean and I would like to respond if
possible.


Oh boy....well, how many would you like? LOL. See, I don't mind the
examples, but you are probably going to disagree with what I offer

<snip>

evil. --
Be as you are.

From alt.atheism only...Julie Kale (aa 1029)
www.juliekale.com


juliekale -
Very nice response.
.

User: "Elroy Willis"

Title: Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE ! 15 Aug 2003 05:27:39 PM
(Kix Adams) wrote in alt.atheism

That person was Jesus Christ. And the
reason this perfect man was beaten, stabbed, nailed to a cross and
spent three days in hell, was to pay the price for ALL of us who
choose to accept the firgiveness and salvation he offers. Kind of like
having someone offer to pay all your traffic tickets for you.

You're afraid to take responsibility for your own actions? You need
someone to take the blame for you, instead of taking it yourself, eh?
--
Elroy Willis
EAP Chief Editor and Newshound
http://web2.airmail.net/~elo/news
.

User: "JessHC"

Title: Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE ! 14 Aug 2003 09:41:15 AM
(Kix Adams) wrote in message news:<6ee1b361.0308132359.6a399d64@posting.google.com>...

"juliekale" <me[spammenot]@juliekale.com> wrote in message news:<sUe_a.30684$qg3.2040176@twister.tampabay.rr.com>...


It's so very interesting to me that in the bible you see so many examples of
children paying for the sins of their parents, despite the fact that this is
supposed to be something god finds unjust and unreasonable.


Could you give me an example of what you're talking about? Because I'm
not real clear on what you mean and I would like to respond if
possible.

You're talking about one mistake made by two ignorant people who were not
told that their actions would cause such great harm to humanity, and yet
your loving god has chosen to punish the whole of humanity for something we
had nothing to do with.


Oh, but it wasn't a mistake. A mistake is when you innocently do
something out of pure ignorance, like turning down a one way street
because the sign was missing that warned you not to enter. This, on
the other hand was a concious, deliberate decision to disobey the ONE
commandment God gave them. Claiming this act was a mistake is what a
small child would say in order to get out of punishement after he
deliberately wrote all over the wall with a magic marker. Did I
explain that well enough for you to see the difference?

Would a loving parent torture a child, and all that child's offspring
through eternity, for eternity, for making one wrong choice? Why
would a loving god refuse to forgive one bad choice, particularly when
he knew that the person making the choice lacked the knowledge to
understand the consequences?

Oh, and the fact that God has forgiving me of every sin I've commited
in my life and promises he will do the same for anyone tells me that
he is indeed a V-E-R-Y loving God.

As long as you do what he says.

Why should I seek forgivness when I had no part in creating my own sinful
nature?


We don't ask forgiveness for having a sinful nature. We ask
forgiveness for all the times we've given into that nature. Adam and
Eve basically told God, by their actions that they wanted the free
will to choose beteen doing good and doing evil. God gave them that
free will, but as we've heard many times lately, freedom isn't free.
We are ALL tempted, every last one of us, and every last one of us
gives in at one time or another. The price of those sins is eternal
damnation, if we don't ask for forgiveness for them.

Who established that rule?
<snip>
.

User: "Barry OGrady"

Title: Re: God KILLED his SON for one rotten APPLE ! 15 Aug 2003 09:29:35 AM
On 14 Aug 2003 00:59:45 -0700,
(Kix Adams) wrote:

"juliekale" <me[spammenot]@juliekale.com> wrote in message news:<sUe_a.30684$qg3.2040176@twister.tampabay.rr.com>...


It's so very interesting to me that in the bible you see so many examples of
children paying for the sins of their parents, despite the fact that this is
supposed to be something god finds unjust and unreasonable.


Could you give me an example of what you're talking about? Because I'm
not real clear on what you mean and I would like to respond if
possible.

You should read the Bible.

You're talking about one mistake made by two ignorant people who were not
told that their actions would cause such great harm to humanity, and yet
your loving god has chosen to punish the whole of humanity for something we
had nothing to do with.


Oh, but it wasn't a mistake. A mistake is when you innocently do
something out of pure ignorance, like turning down a one way street
because the sign was missing that warned you not to enter. This, on
the other hand was a concious, deliberate decision to disobey the ONE
commandment God gave them. Claiming this act was a mistake is what a
small child would say in order to get out of punishement after he
deliberately wrote all over the wall with a magic marker. Did I
explain that well enough for you to see the difference?

I see the difference. It would have been a mistake if A and E knew the
difference between right and wrong, but that didn't happen until after
the tree scam. It was a deliberate decision by God to use them as an
excuse to downgrade all of creation.
God is the sort that would remove the one way sign and rejoice when cars
collide.

Oh, and the fact that God has forgiving me of every sin I've commited
in my life and promises he will do the same for anyone tells me that
he is indeed a V-E-R-Y loving God.

God should forgive us for being as he made us, but should we forgive God?

Why should I seek forgivness when I had no part in creating my own sinful
nature?


We don't ask forgiveness for having a sinful nature. We ask
forgiveness for all the times we've given into that nature.

Why must we fight our God given nature?

Adam and
Eve basically told God, by their actions that they wanted the free
will to choose beteen doing good and doing evil. God gave them that
free will, but as we've heard many times lately, freedom isn't free.
We are ALL tempted, every last one of us, and every last one of us
gives in at one time or another. The price of those sins is eternal
damnation, if we don't ask for forgiveness for them.

We are the victims here. You would punish a child for having abusive parents.

But that really is a very easy thing to do.. if you listen to what God has
put in your heart.

God put a shooshing sound in my heart.

There has only been one person in all the history of mankind who was
totally innocent of any sin.. That person was Jesus Christ.

Why didn't God make us all totally innocent of any sin?

And the
reason this perfect man was beaten, stabbed, nailed to a cross and
spent three days in hell, was to pay the price for ALL of us who
choose to accept the firgiveness and salvation he offers. Kind of like
having someone offer to pay all your traffic tickets for you. He has
promised us that if we come to him in prayer and gives our lives over
to him in sincere repentence then our debt is paid in full and
forgiveness is ours, JUST FOR THE ASKING.

Wow! So, only after God was appeased by a stupid ritual was he able
to forgive us for being the way he made us. God could have made us
all perfect but then he would have had no excuse to abuse us.

Without it, we go from god's frying pan into his fire.


I don't know that I would call this life God's frying pan. *smile* I
think mankind has to pretty much bear the responsibility for this
world being as messed up as it is.

It's not our fault, but our creator refuses to accept responsibility for what
he has created. If we don't work at overcoming our God given nature we
won't get ahead.

But, we do have a choice about where we will go when this life is over.

We can choose either lack of existence or non-existance.

That is a promise from God himself.

God has never failed to let us down.
-Barry
========
Web page: http://members.optusnet.com.au/~barry.og
Atheist, radio scanner, LIPD information.
Voicemail/fax number +14136227640
.


  Page 1 of 1

1

 


Related Articles
 

NEWER

pg.3585     pg.2749     pg.2106     pg.1612     pg.1232     pg.940     pg.716     pg.544     pg.412     pg.311     pg.234     pg.175     pg.130     pg.96     pg.70     pg.50     pg.35     pg.24     pg.16     pg.10     pg.6     pg.3     pg.1

OLDER