Did God Create Carnivores?



 Religions > Bible > Did God Create Carnivores?

LINK TO THIS PAGE  


rating :  0   |  0


  Page 1 of 1

1

 
Topic: Religions > Bible
User: "DDBible"
Date: 04 Aug 2005 09:31:44 AM
Object: Did God Create Carnivores?
I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?
.

User: "Milan"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 04 Aug 2005 06:26:49 PM
"DDBible" <DDBible@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1123165904.851309.217530@g49g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...

I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?

Not much really. What's your point?
regards
Milan
.
User: "Libertarius"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 09 Aug 2005 09:19:59 PM
Milan wrote:

"DDBible" <DDBible@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:1123165904.851309.217530@g49g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...

I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?


Not much really. What's your point?

===>It says that any "God" is just an IDOL, created by
human imagination. -- L.
.


User: "Ben Mitts"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 04 Aug 2005 10:25:59 AM
DDBible wrote:

I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?

What do you have to say about God?
--
May God continue to richly Bless you!
Peace and Love in The Name of Jesus Christ!
Sincerely,
Ben mitts
".. Feed your Faith, starve your doubts ..."
From The Word of God: And as Moses lifted up the serpent
in the wilderness, even so must the Son of Man be lifted
up; that whoever believes may in Him have eternal life."
Similarly, God so loved the world, that He gave His only
begotten Son, that who ever believes in Him should not
perish, but Have Eternal life.
Therefore, we may, as many will to do so: "But as many as
received Him, to them He gave the right to become child-
ren of God, even to those who believe in His name,"
(John 1:12)
.
User: "Libertarius"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 09 Aug 2005 09:18:30 PM
Ben Mitts wrote:

DDBible wrote:

I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?


What do you have to say about God?

===>You can say anything you wish.
So have all the writers compiled in the Bible,
as well as all the priests and preachers since
time immemorial.
Any "God" is just an IDOL, created by human imagination. -- L.
.


User: "Your Name Here=Harvey"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 05 Aug 2005 06:37:00 PM
In article <1123165904.851309.217530@g49g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
DDBible@hotmail.com says...


I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?

This is exactly the sort of questioning you should continue with
and seek answers for.
Relating back to the real world, and see if what you are taught,
or read, makes any real sense at all.
I think your question relates more to the nature of 'God' that you
believe in?
There are 3? general interpretations of God.
1. The God of the Bible - so called believers believe in biblical text
as being their truth, but this so called truth doesn't relate well
back to this real world in which we live. So you are going to have
a very hard time, keeping your belief in the bible, as you try to
understand the world in which we live.
There are a great number of questions which the God of the Bible
cannot answer to, satisfactorily - you mention only one of them.
2. God as being nature, science and the world around you.
What created everything in the world, including ourselves? God?
Some say - oh, yes - God did all that. And even if you don't believe,
that whatever created everything (and how this universe runs) was
due to God.
But that is only one way of looking at it.
Another way is (and this is how the original 'Jesus' taught - which
is not included in the bible, see www.tjresearch.info) that there
is the Creation (not to be confused with 'God' or god - there being
none at all) - and creation is the process by which everything runs, and
is governed by. That Planets evolve by themselves (via the Creation)
developing life naturally - that planets which are capable of supporting
life, will eventually develop life, in their natural process (they
can also artificially develop life, greatly speeded up via interstellar
seeding - like from Galactic races exploring the universe).
Anyway the Creation does not need to have a creator at all. It is like
the analogy of there being only 'light' and not 'darkness' as such, but
merely the presence of no-light or absence of light. There is love or
the absence of love, and not love and hate, as such. The presence of
heat or the absence of heat, etc etc.
3. Any other view you wish to put forward. But I think the above covers
almost everything?
I don't believe in 1. because it is not a sane, logical and loving god.
Some people believe that god is love - well a god who destroys a human race
because they are living in sin, etc is hardly a loving god.
Nor one who kills people whenever he feels like it - whether there is any
justification in it, or not.
There comes a time in everyone's life, when you have to question everything
you learned - and make up your own mind, whether you truly believe in it,
or not? You simply cannot assume that what you are taught, is always
truthful - you must work out the logic yourself, what is true and what isn't.
Remember that science teaches the current theory (or knowledge) of the time,
and this does change and gets updated - slowly.
I personally think it is time for a radical change in the world consciousness,
because the issues of religion ought to be addressed, which are long, long,
long overdue. Religion has to be taken to task for many of it's claims,
because we can actually sort it all out now. If only people would look
over the information and answer the most basic logical questions relating
to all this. Which can be done.
The reason why it isn't, is to not upset the status quo - of the current
authorities of/in the world.
The truth is shocking and very surprising - because what we have been fed
as the truth, for so long - is not the truth at all.
For people to know the truth today, would mean a complete shift in the
power structure of the current world. Actually it would mean a much freer
world, in which there would be no limits to the knowledge people wish access
to, we would have much more technologic progress along with the spiritual
development necessary so that we could live in a golden age of peace and
understanding.
Harvey
.
User: "Libertarius"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 09 Aug 2005 09:38:54 PM
Your Name Here=Harvey wrote:

In article <1123165904.851309.217530@g49g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>,
DDBible@hotmail.com says...


I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?


This is exactly the sort of questioning you should continue with
and seek answers for.
Relating back to the real world, and see if what you are taught,
or read, makes any real sense at all.

I think your question relates more to the nature of 'God' that you
believe in?
There are 3? general interpretations of God.

1. The God of the Bible

===>An IDOL created by human imagination.

- so called believers believe in biblical text
as being their truth, but this so called truth doesn't relate well
back to this real world in which we live. So you are going to have
a very hard time, keeping your belief in the bible, as you try to
understand the world in which we live.
There are a great number of questions which the God of the Bible
cannot answer to, satisfactorily - you mention only one of them.

2. God as being nature, science and the world around you.

===>"Spinoza's God" -- so called by Albert Einstein.

What created everything in the world, including ourselves? God?
Some say - oh, yes - God did all that. And even if you don't believe,
that whatever created everything (and how this universe runs) was
due to God.
But that is only one way of looking at it.
Another way is (and this is how the original 'Jesus' taught

===>Actually, it was another Jew named BARUCH. (See above).

- which
is not included in the bible, see www.tjresearch.info) that there
is the Creation (not to be confused with 'God' or god - there being
none at all) - and creation is the process by which everything runs, and
is governed by. That Planets evolve by themselves (via the Creation)
developing life naturally - that planets which are capable of supporting
life, will eventually develop life, in their natural process (they
can also artificially develop life, greatly speeded up via interstellar
seeding - like from Galactic races exploring the universe).
Anyway the Creation does not need to have a creator at all. It is like
the analogy of there being only 'light' and not 'darkness' as such, but
merely the presence of no-light or absence of light. There is love or
the absence of love, and not love and hate, as such. The presence of
heat or the absence of heat, etc etc.

3. Any other view you wish to put forward. But I think the above covers
almost everything?

I don't believe in 1. because it is not a sane, logical and loving god.
Some people believe that god is love - well a god who destroys a human race
because they are living in sin, etc is hardly a loving god.
Nor one who kills people whenever he feels like it - whether there is any
justification in it, or not.

There comes a time in everyone's life, when you have to question everything
you learned - and make up your own mind, whether you truly believe in it,
or not? You simply cannot assume that what you are taught, is always
truthful - you must work out the logic yourself, what is true and what isn't.
Remember that science teaches the current theory (or knowledge) of the time,
and this does change and gets updated - slowly.

I personally think it is time for a radical change in the world consciousness,
because the issues of religion ought to be addressed, which are long, long,
long overdue. Religion has to be taken to task for many of it's claims,
because we can actually sort it all out now. If only people would look
over the information and answer the most basic logical questions relating
to all this. Which can be done.
The reason why it isn't, is to not upset the status quo - of the current
authorities of/in the world.
The truth is shocking and very surprising - because what we have been fed
as the truth, for so long - is not the truth at all.
For people to know the truth today, would mean a complete shift in the
power structure of the current world. Actually it would mean a much freer
world, in which there would be no limits to the knowledge people wish access
to, we would have much more technologic progress along with the spiritual
development necessary so that we could live in a golden age of peace and
understanding.

Harvey

.


User: "Pastor Dave"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 04 Aug 2005 10:17:16 AM
On 4 Aug 2005 07:31:44 -0700, "DDBible"
<DDBible@hotmail.com> spake thusly:

I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?

Nothing ate meat before the Flood.
--
Pastor Dave
A person cannot be relying on Christ
if he chooses to chart his own life
course in opposition to Christ from
the very outset of his faith relationship.
Christ as a whole person, Lord & Savior,
is the Gospel message, not simply the
fact that Christ died for sin. If you
have not made Him Lord, then He is not
your Savior (John 14:21,24).
http://www.ecclesia.org/truth/solution.html
http://tinyurl.com/ce97m
.
User: "Andrew W"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 04 Aug 2005 04:38:42 PM
"Pastor Dave" <news-group-mail@nospam-tampa-bay.rr.com> wrote in message
news:59c4f1tdqqfd6nqd4bl8drkc08vgeaifgp@4ax.com...

On 4 Aug 2005 07:31:44 -0700, "DDBible"
<DDBible@hotmail.com> spake thusly:


I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?


Nothing ate meat before the Flood.

God is responsible for the flood so God made every creature start eating
each other.
--
Andrew W.
Free-mindedness is foolishness to those whose brains are perishing.
Religion Exposed!
http://members.optusnet.com.au/~ajwerner
.

User: "DDBible"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 05 Aug 2005 10:30:21 AM
Pastor Dave wrote:

Nothing ate meat before the Flood.

That is one interpretation but there's problems with that...animals
have brilliantly designed hunting and defensive techniques that could
NOT have occurred by genetic mutations alone- too
complex....unless,,,,,,, Although God obviously provided his "kinds"
with staggeringly varied adapting possibilities (micro-evolution-
speciation), are we to believe he also stored genetic material that
would turn herbivores into carnivores if need be? I'm a God-believer no
doubt- I just have yet to hear a convincing answer to the question of
carnivores. When I see a cheetah shred a doe I don't feel like praising
the wonderful creator, do you?
.
User: "Libertarius"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 09 Aug 2005 09:33:17 PM
DDBible wrote:

Pastor Dave wrote:

Nothing ate meat before the Flood.


That is one interpretation but there's problems with that...animals
have brilliantly designed hunting and defensive techniques that could
NOT have occurred by genetic mutations alone-

===>But that's EXACTLY the way they "occurred".
The ET intervention theory (a.k.a. "Intelligent Design")
is just an intelligently (cleverly) designed myth, produced to serve
the unintelligent, uneducated "believers". -- L.
.

User: "Pastor Dave"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 06 Aug 2005 12:55:54 PM
On 5 Aug 2005 08:30:21 -0700, "DDBible"
<DDBible@hotmail.com> spake thusly:

Pastor Dave wrote:

Nothing ate meat before the Flood.


That is one interpretation

There is "interpretation". it is what
the Bible clearly says. Either believe
it, or don't. But don't try to tell me
it's "an interpretation".
--
Pastor Dave
"If you believe what you like in the Gospel,
and reject what you like - it is not the Gospel
you believe, but yourselves." - St. Augustine
http://www.ecclesia.org/truth/solution.html
http://tinyurl.com/ce97m
.


User: "Steven J."

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 04 Aug 2005 11:17:20 PM
Pastor Dave wrote:

On 4 Aug 2005 07:31:44 -0700, "DDBible"
<DDBible@hotmail.com> spake thusly:


I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?


Nothing ate meat before the Flood.

Out of idle curiousity, are insects "meat?" Did anteaters eat plants
before the flood? Did carnivorous beetles and ant lions? I ask this
because some creationists make a distinction between _nephesh_ life and
non-_nephesh_ life that does not seem quite identical to the
distinction between animals and non-animals.
What did whales eat before the flood? Currently, all whales are
carnivorous, although the immense baleen whales eat very small prey
(shrimp-like crustaceans), while killer whales tend to go for other
aquatic mammals and sperm whales are reputed to eat giant squids.
Many carnivores have what appear to be striking adaptions for
predation: cats are well engineered, e.g. for pouncing on and
disembowling prey. Rattlesnakes have those hollow retractible poison
fangs. Were these "original equipment," or were these and other
predators re-engineered (rather drastically, one would imagine) after
the Flood? One might imagine that a lot of the (vegetarian) "kinds"
that marched off the Ark did not much resemble their (carnivorous)
descendants, but in your opinion would one be right to imagine that?
To the extent that species were "re-engineered" after the Flood, how
did this happen?


--

Pastor Dave

-- [snip]


-- Steven J.
.
User: "Libertarius"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 09 Aug 2005 09:28:41 PM
"Steven J." wrote:

Pastor Dave wrote:

On 4 Aug 2005 07:31:44 -0700, "DDBible"
<DDBible@hotmail.com> spake thusly:


I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?


Nothing ate meat before the Flood.

Out of idle curiousity, are insects "meat?" Did anteaters eat plants
before the flood?

===>Of course. They were all vegetarian Seventh-Day Adventists.

Did carnivorous beetles and ant lions?

===>Of course. They were all vegetarian Seventh-Day Adventists.

I ask this
because some creationists make a distinction between _nephesh_ life and
non-_nephesh_ life that does not seem quite identical to the
distinction between animals and non-animals.

What did whales eat before the flood?

===>There were no whales before the flood.
Some fish were turned into whales by the turbulence.

Currently, all whales are
carnivorous, although the immense baleen whales eat very small prey
(shrimp-like crustaceans), while killer whales tend to go for other
aquatic mammals and sperm whales are reputed to eat giant squids.

Many carnivores have what appear to be striking adaptions for
predation: cats are well engineered, e.g. for pouncing on and
disembowling prey. Rattlesnakes have those hollow retractible poison
fangs.

===>They got that way after YHWH cursed the snakes for revealing
the truth to Adam and Eve.

Were these "original equipment," or were these and other
predators re-engineered (rather drastically, one would imagine) after
the Flood?

===>Retrofitted with fangs.

One might imagine that a lot of the (vegetarian) "kinds"
that marched off the Ark did not much resemble their (carnivorous)
descendants, but in your opinion would one be right to imagine that?

===>Of course.
All religion IS about imagining and imaginary things.

To the extent that species were "re-engineered" after the Flood, how
did this happen?

===>YHWH did it when he realized he was sorry he did it
the wrong way before the flood. Without killing animals,
there could be no sacrifices, and he sure enjoyed the smell
of meat roasting on the altar of Noah! (See Genesis 6-8). -- L.
.

User: "Al Smith"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 05 Aug 2005 05:32:05 PM

Many carnivores have what appear to be striking adaptions for
predation: cats are well engineered, e.g. for pouncing on and
disembowling prey. Rattlesnakes have those hollow retractible poison
fangs. Were these "original equipment," or were these and other
predators re-engineered (rather drastically, one would imagine) after
the Flood? One might imagine that a lot of the (vegetarian) "kinds"
that marched off the Ark did not much resemble their (carnivorous)
descendants, but in your opinion would one be right to imagine that?
To the extent that species were "re-engineered" after the Flood, how
did this happen?

I'm going to go out on a limb here, and say that Noah had a
genetics laboratory under the poop deck. And on the Ark, they
didn't call it a poop deck for nothing.
.


User: "Libertarius"

Title: Re: Did God Create Carnivores? 09 Aug 2005 09:16:05 PM
Pastor Dave wrote:

On 4 Aug 2005 07:31:44 -0700, "DDBible"
<DDBible@hotmail.com> spake thusly:

I have to admit- the fact that nature is bloody and seemingly cruel is
a stumbling block for me. Can folks here give their thoughts (and
Biblical support) for whether God created carnivores or not. If he
did...what does that say about God?


Nothing ate meat before the Flood.

===>Thus, since there was no "Flood",
nothing eats meat to this day.
Seriously, when the ET named YHWH sculpted all
those animals and men out of mud and blew air
into their noses, he made some of them LOOK LIKE
they were meat eaters, but in fact they were all
originally vegetarian Seventh-Day Adventists. -- L.
.



  Page 1 of 1

1

 


Related Articles
Was "Re: Did God Create Carnivores?"
Did any real god create this?
Why God did not create the sun on the fourth day ...
WHY DID THE ALL-LOVING GOD CREATE E.COLI?
Re: Why did God create handicapped people?
Re: Why did God create handicapped people?
Re: Did God create the earth and everything else through Jesus ?
Re: HUMAN NATURE: "HUMAN NATURE--Did God Create It?" by Herbert W. Armstrong
WHY DID THE ALL-LOVING GOD CREATE SNAKES THAT KILL PEOPLE?
You did not and do not create yourselves.
why did the all-powerful creator create evil?
You did not and do not create yourselves...3
Re: Did humans "imagine-up" almighty beings or did an almighty being or almighty beings create humans?
You did not and do not create yourselves...2
If the New Covenant did not obsolete the Old Covenant, why don't we follow the Law of Moses?
 

NEWER

pg.1232     pg.940     pg.716     pg.544     pg.412     pg.311     pg.234     pg.175     pg.130     pg.96     pg.70     pg.50     pg.35     pg.24     pg.16     pg.10     pg.6     pg.3     pg.1

OLDER