On What Little Meaning You May Have



 Science > Philosophy > On What Little Meaning You May Have

LINK TO THIS PAGE  


rating :  0   |  0


  Page 1 of 1

1

 
Topic: Science > Philosophy
User: "Sir Frederick"
Date: 21 Jan 2006 08:55:29 PM
Object: On What Little Meaning You May Have
http://www.edge.org/q2005/q05_3.html

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF
Media Analyst; Documentary Writer; Author, Media Virus

I can't prove it more than anecdotally, but I believe evolution has purpose and direction. It appears obvious, yet absolutely unconfirmable, that matter is groping towards complexity. While the laws of nature—and time itself—require objects and life forms attain durability and sustainability for survival, it seems to me more a means to an end than an end in itself.

Theology goes a long way towards imbuing substance and processes with meaning—describing life as "matter reaching towards divinity," or as the process through which divinity calls matter back up into itself—but theologians repeatedly make the mistake of ascribing this sense of purpose to history rather than the future. This is only natural, since the narrative structures we use to understand our world tend to have beginnings, middles, and ends. In order to experience the pay-off at the end of the story, we need to see it as somehow built-in to the original intention of events.

It's also hard for people to contend with the great probability that we are simply over-advanced fungi and bacteria, hurling through a galaxy in cold and meaningless space. Our existence may be unintentional, meaningless and purposeless; but that doesn't preclude meaning or purpose from emerging as a result of our interaction and collaboration. Meaning may not be a precondition for humanity, but rather a byproduct of it.

That's why it's so important to recognize that evolution, at its best, is a team sport. As Darwin's later, lesser-known, but more important works contended, survival of the fittest is not a law applied to individuals, but to groups. Just as it is now postulated that mosquitoes cause their victims to itch and sweat nervously so that other mosquitoes can more easily find the target, most great leaps forward in human evolution—from the formation of clans to the building of cities—are feats of collaborative effort. Better rates of survival are as much a happy side effect of good collaboration as their purpose.

If we could stop relating to meaning and purpose as artifacts of some divine creative act, and see them instead as the yield of our own creative future, they become goals, intentions, and processes very much in reach—rather than the shadows of childlike, superstitious mythology

The proof is impossible, since it is an unfolding one. Like reaching a horizon, arrival merely necessitates more travel.

.

User: "Edgar Svendsen"

Title: Re: On What Little Meaning You May Have 21 Jan 2006 09:09:52 PM
"Sir Frederick" <mmcneill@fuzzysys.com> wrote in message
news:8ls5t1ha17vmdmgq779ivmat8nnla4dhdu@4ax.com...

http://www.edge.org/q2005/q05_3.html

DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF
Media Analyst; Documentary Writer; Author, Media Virus

I can't prove it more than anecdotally, but I believe evolution has
purpose and direction. It appears obvious, yet absolutely unconfirmable,
that matter is groping towards complexity. While the laws of nature-and
time itself-require objects and life forms attain durability and
sustainability for survival, it seems to me more a means to an end than an
end in itself.

Theology goes a long way towards imbuing substance and processes with
meaning-describing life as "matter reaching towards divinity," or as the
process through which divinity calls matter back up into itself-but
theologians repeatedly make the mistake of ascribing this sense of purpose
to history rather than the future. This is only natural, since the
narrative structures we use to understand our world tend to have
beginnings, middles, and ends. In order to experience the pay-off at the
end of the story, we need to see it as somehow built-in to the original
intention of events.

It's also hard for people to contend with the great probability that we
are simply over-advanced fungi and bacteria, hurling through a galaxy in
cold and meaningless space. Our existence may be unintentional,
meaningless and purposeless; but that doesn't preclude meaning or purpose
from emerging as a result of our interaction and collaboration. Meaning
may not be a precondition for humanity, but rather a byproduct of it.

That's why it's so important to recognize that evolution, at its best, is
a team sport. As Darwin's later, lesser-known, but more important works
contended, survival of the fittest is not a law applied to individuals,
but to groups. Just as it is now postulated that mosquitoes cause their
victims to itch and sweat nervously so that other mosquitoes can more
easily find the target, most great leaps forward in human evolution-from
the formation of clans to the building of cities-are feats of
collaborative effort. Better rates of survival are as much a happy side
effect of good collaboration as their purpose.

None of these "great leaps" have anything to do with evolution. Evolution
is displayed in changes in the DNA of groups, neither clans nor cities are
correlated with changes in the DNA of Homo Sapiens, they are cultural
achievements.
It may be that, in due time, there will be evolutionary changes in Homo Sap.
due to clans and cities but that hasn't happened yet. Things would probably
work much better if it had.
Ed

If we could stop relating to meaning and purpose as artifacts of some
divine creative act, and see them instead as the yield of our own creative
future, they become goals, intentions, and processes very much in
reach-rather than the shadows of childlike, superstitious mythology

The proof is impossible, since it is an unfolding one. Like reaching a
horizon, arrival merely necessitates more travel.

.


  Page 1 of 1

1

 


Related Articles
Re: "Grandpa, can you tell me how Bush became our beloved Dictator?" asked little Timmy
Everything you own takes a little piece ~ peace of you
Re: "Grandpa, can you tell me how Bush became our beloved Dictator?"asked little Timmy
Re: "Grandpa, can you tell me how Bush became our beloved Dictator?" asked little Timmy
Re: "Grandpa, can you tell me how Bush became our beloved Dictator?" asked little Timmy
Re: "Grandpa, can you tell me how Bush became our beloved Dictator?" asked little Timmy
Who are you?
888 Keywords show Gods Signs - Now you can believe!!!
Re: It's OK if you don't believe in GOD but............
Are you white and love your race?
Don't ask what belongs to you - ask what you belong to.
How Do You Like Me Now?
can you ring 511 for me...if you can
J of 3r do you still post here
Re: Good morning or good evening depending upon your location. I want to ask you the most important question of your life. Your joy or sorrow for all eternity depends upon your answer. The question is: Are you saved? It is not a question of how good
 

NEWER

pg.716     pg.544     pg.412     pg.311     pg.234     pg.175     pg.130     pg.96     pg.70     pg.50     pg.35     pg.24     pg.16     pg.10     pg.6     pg.3     pg.1

OLDER