Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets



 Science > Physics > Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets

LINK TO THIS PAGE  


rating :  0   |  0


  Page 1 of 1

1

 
Topic: Science > Physics
User: "Sam Wormley"
Date: 09 Nov 2005 09:55:41 PM
Object: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets
Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6
Two teams of physicists have discovered previously unseen exotic
behaviour in sheets of carbon atoms. The teams have shown that electrons
move through the sheets as if they have no rest mass. They have also
observed a minimum value of conductivity for the sheets and an unusual
form of the quantum Hall effect (Nature 438 197 and 201).
.

User: "Y.Porat"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 10 Nov 2005 03:41:56 AM
1 did QM predicted that??
i guess as usual
after finding the experimental data
the QM wizard will get up ans say
Oh yes we can explain it .....
2 The fact the electrons move much faster than expected is far away
from calling them
the stupid name -- massless!!
3 remember the new iron rule of physics:
'no mass - no real physics'!!
4 have you ever hear ed about the idea
of 'chain of orbitals' ??
in such a case there is no need that the electrons will move (or may be
move much less than usual in conductors.
ATB
Y.Porat
------------------------
.

User: "Sam Wormley"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 11 Nov 2005 12:24:00 AM
Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

Two teams of physicists have discovered previously unseen exotic
behaviour in sheets of carbon atoms. The teams have shown that electrons
move through the sheets as if they have no rest mass. They have also
observed a minimum value of conductivity for the sheets and an unusual
form of the quantum Hall effect (Nature 438 197 and 201).

Experimental Observation of Quantum Hall Effect and Berry's Phase in Graphene
http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0509355
Authors: Yuanbo Zhang, Yan-Wen Tan, Horst L. Stormer, Philip Kim
Subj-class: Mesoscopic Systems and Quantum Hall Effect; Strongly Correlated Electrons
When electrons are confined in two-dimensional (2D) materials,
quantum mechanically enhanced transport phenomena, as exemplified
by the quantum Hall effects (QHE), can be observed. Graphene, an
isolated single atomic layer of graphite, is an ideal realization
of such a 2D system. Here, we report an experimental investigation
of magneto transport in a high mobility single layer of graphene.
Adjusting the chemical potential using the electric field effect,
we observe an unusual half integer QHE for both electron and hole
carriers in graphene. Vanishing effective carrier masses is
observed at Dirac point in the temperature dependent Shubnikov de
Haas oscillations, which probe the 'relativistic' Dirac
particle-like dispersion. The relevance of Berry's phase to these
experiments is confirmed by the phase shift of
magneto-oscillations, related to the exceptional topology of the
graphene band structure.
See: http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0509355
.
User: "Y.Porat"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 11 Nov 2005 01:10:57 AM
Sam Wormley wrote:

Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

nd 201).



Experimental Observation of Quantum Hall Effect and Berry's Phase in Graphene
http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0509355

Authors: Yuanbo Zhang, Yan-Wen Tan, Horst L. Stormer, Philip Kim
Subj-class: Mesoscopic Systems and Quantum Hall Effect; Strongly Correlated Electrons

When electrons are confined in two-dimensional (2D) materials,
quantum mechanically enhanced transport phenomena, as exemplified
by the quantum Hall effects (QHE), can be observed. Graphene, an
isolated single atomic layer of graphite, is an ideal realization
of such a 2D system. Here, we report an experimental investigation
of magneto transport in a high mobility single layer of graphene.
Adjusting the chemical potential using the electric field effect,
we observe an unusual half integer QHE for both electron and hole
carriers in graphene. Vanishing effective carrier masses is
observed at Dirac point in the temperature dependent Shubnikov de
Haas oscillations, which probe the 'relativistic' Dirac

-------------------
have you heared about the new basic physics law:
'No mass - No real physics'
it is a new 'litmus paper' to distinguish between real physics
and speculative mumbling.
once you start to talk about :
'vanishing effective Carrier masses'
you lost the physics ground beneath your legs
and start mathematical mumblings
or at the good case - speculative vague and most probably
useless physics
in more simple words:
physics that does not lead you far away
may be in the good case some very partial extrapolation of data
(that is the only real power of mathematics but no *real* physics.)
without knowing why and how.
or still in other words very far from getting to the physics scratch.

----------------

ATB
Y.Porat
------------------------------
.
User: "jesper pedersen"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 12 Nov 2005 07:45:00 AM
"Y.Porat" <maporat@012.net.il> wrote in message
news:1131693057.624486.210950@g47g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...


Sam Wormley wrote:

Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

nd 201).



Experimental Observation of Quantum Hall Effect and Berry's Phase in
Graphene
http://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0509355

Authors: Yuanbo Zhang, Yan-Wen Tan, Horst L. Stormer, Philip Kim
Subj-class: Mesoscopic Systems and Quantum Hall Effect; Strongly
Correlated Electrons

When electrons are confined in two-dimensional (2D) materials,
quantum mechanically enhanced transport phenomena, as exemplified
by the quantum Hall effects (QHE), can be observed. Graphene, an
isolated single atomic layer of graphite, is an ideal realization
of such a 2D system. Here, we report an experimental investigation
of magneto transport in a high mobility single layer of graphene.
Adjusting the chemical potential using the electric field effect,
we observe an unusual half integer QHE for both electron and hole
carriers in graphene. Vanishing effective carrier masses is
observed at Dirac point in the temperature dependent Shubnikov de
Haas oscillations, which probe the 'relativistic' Dirac

-------------------
have you heared about the new basic physics law:

'No mass - No real physics'
it is a new 'litmus paper' to distinguish between real physics
and speculative mumbling.

once you start to talk about :
'vanishing effective Carrier masses'
you lost the physics ground beneath your legs
and start mathematical mumblings
or at the good case - speculative vague and most probably
useless physics
in more simple words:
physics that does not lead you far away
may be in the good case some very partial extrapolation of data
(that is the only real power of mathematics but no *real* physics.)

without knowing why and how.
or still in other words very far from getting to the physics scratch.

Or in other words: You have absolutely no idea what "effective carrier mass"
means, do you?
/ Jesper P
.
User: "Y.Porat"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 13 Nov 2005 02:10:59 AM
no i dont know !
do you know ???...........
if yes please explain it to an ignorant
PS
do you agree with me about the general rule (not necessary this
specific case)
that:
'No mass - no real physics??
TIA
Y.Porat
-------------------
.
User: ""

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 13 Nov 2005 05:43:30 PM
Y.Porat wrote:

no i dont know !

do you know ???...........
if yes please explain it to an ignorant

PS
do you agree with me about the general rule (not necessary this
specific case)

that:
'No mass - no real physics??

TIA
Y.Porat
-------------------

Mr. Porat, just got my copy of the NATURE journal, Vol 438, 10
November 2005 .
You can get copies, on line,
of those papers on Dirac fermions and the Berry phase in graphene..
It might be interesting for you to acquire the letters and see what
you think of their results.
Try:
www.nature.com/nature
The papers are available in full text or on pdf.
A fractional quantum hall effect is occuring with both holes and
electrons, so that leads them into saying the electron is massless. (Of
course the electron is not massless, and a least one of them said so.)
Regards: Tom;
I just started on my 80th year so, sorry, I cannot engage in a long
discourse.
.
User: "Sam Wormley"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 13 Nov 2005 05:53:03 PM
wrote:

Y.Porat wrote:

no i dont know !

do you know ???...........
if yes please explain it to an ignorant

PS
do you agree with me about the general rule (not necessary this
specific case)

that:
'No mass - no real physics??

TIA
Y.Porat
-------------------



Mr. Porat, just got my copy of the NATURE journal, Vol 438, 10
November 2005 .

You can get copies, on line,

of those papers on Dirac fermions and the Berry phase in graphene..

It might be interesting for you to acquire the letters and see what
you think of their results.

Try:

www.nature.com/nature

The papers are available in full text or on pdf.

A fractional quantum hall effect is occuring with both holes and
electrons, so that leads them into saying the electron is massless. (Of
course the electron is not massless, and a least one of them said so.)

Regards: Tom;

I just started on my 80th year so, sorry, I cannot engage in a long
discourse.

Come on Tom... shoot for at least 96!
.

User: "Y.Porat"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 13 Nov 2005 11:17:32 PM
OK
1 thank you Tom.
2 so even before entering the above issue
do you start to see the power of my simple postulate??
no mass -- no real physics!!
i now nothing about all that 'haall effect'
yet before even knowing anything-
the moment anyone suggest 'no mass' or massless'
it becomes immediately according to my new postulate--
*dead by arrival*
so its use is - preventing getting lost and wasting precious time
on wrong directions
it tels the innovator:
'come on'! you are not in the right direction- look for a
correction!!
(according to the iron rule no mass- no real physics' or
better look for the hiding mass!!)
do you start to agree with me ??
TIA
Y.Porat
----------------------
.
User: "Happy Hippy"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 14 Nov 2005 09:56:48 AM
Y.Porat wrote:

OK

1 thank you Tom.

2 so even before entering the above issue

do you start to see the power of my simple postulate??

no mass -- no real physics!!

i now nothing about all that 'haall effect'
yet before even knowing anything-
the moment anyone suggest 'no mass' or massless'
it becomes immediately according to my new postulate--
*dead by arrival*

so its use is - preventing getting lost and wasting precious time
on wrong directions

it tels the innovator:
'come on'! you are not in the right direction- look for a
correction!!
(according to the iron rule no mass- no real physics' or
better look for the hiding mass!!)

do you start to agree with me ??

TIA
Y.Porat
----------------------

Sorry, Y., mass is an effect- not a property
of matter.
John
.
User: "Y.Porat"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 14 Nov 2005 11:31:07 AM
so what are the properties of matter acording to you?
TIA
Y.Porat
-------------------------------
.
User: "Y.Porat"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 15 Nov 2005 01:49:22 AM
and your answer (Mr 'Happy') is ....?????
TIA
Y.Porat
--------------------------
.









User: "RP"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 09 Nov 2005 10:55:10 PM
Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

Two teams of physicists have discovered previously unseen exotic
behaviour in sheets of carbon atoms. The teams have shown that electrons
move through the sheets as if they have no rest mass. They have also
observed a minimum value of conductivity for the sheets and an unusual
form of the quantum Hall effect (Nature 438 197 and 201).

There is no such thing as rest mass. There is however rest energy of a
system of charges (not at rest wrt each other though). m_o = f/a, so
when either f or a equal zero, then m_o is undefined. But only when f
and a are equal zero is the particle at rest wrt an inertial frame. Mass
is meaningful only in the context of relative motion.
And BTW, I predicted that electrons are massless some time ago here,
their curved trajectories are only interpreted as products of inertia,
the rest mass being fictitious. Electrons move along geodesics in curved
space-time. If it works for gravitational fields, then it must also work
for electromagnetic fields. According to Weber, at least two charges are
required in a system in order to derive anything like *mass*.
The unusual form of the Hall effect is probably derivable from Weber's
premises as well.
You can reject my input if it suits you, and I'm sure you know that I'm
not especially dissuaded by so-called acceptable theory, but then again
this isn't the first physicsweb article that has supported my radical
arguments.
In the near future I expect you'll be posting news of electrons having
instantaneous speeds of c wrt each other. Already predicted as well :)
Richard Perry
.
User: "Happy Hippy"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 14 Nov 2005 08:20:07 AM
RP wrote:



Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

Two teams of physicists have discovered previously unseen exotic
behaviour in sheets of carbon atoms. The teams have shown that
electrons
move through the sheets as if they have no rest mass. They have also
observed a minimum value of conductivity for the sheets and an unusual
form of the quantum Hall effect (Nature 438 197 and 201).



There is no such thing as rest mass. There is however rest energy of a
system of charges (not at rest wrt each other though). m_o = f/a, so
when either f or a equal zero, then m_o is undefined. But only when f
and a are equal zero is the particle at rest wrt an inertial frame. Mass
is meaningful only in the context of relative motion.

And BTW, I predicted that electrons are massless some time ago here,
their curved trajectories are only interpreted as products of inertia,
the rest mass being fictitious. Electrons move along geodesics in curved
space-time. If it works for gravitational fields, then it must also work
for electromagnetic fields. According to Weber, at least two charges are
required in a system in order to derive anything like *mass*.

The unusual form of the Hall effect is probably derivable from Weber's
premises as well.

You can reject my input if it suits you, and I'm sure you know that I'm
not especially dissuaded by so-called acceptable theory, but then again
this isn't the first physicsweb article that has supported my radical
arguments.

In the near future I expect you'll be posting news of electrons having
instantaneous speeds of c wrt each other. Already predicted as well :)

Richard Perry

If gravity is a Le Sage type phenom then it
takes considerably more than two members
to register a 'mass'.
John
.
User: "RP"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 14 Nov 2005 12:31:41 PM
Happy Hippy wrote:

RP wrote:



Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

Two teams of physicists have discovered previously unseen exotic
behaviour in sheets of carbon atoms. The teams have shown that
electrons
move through the sheets as if they have no rest mass. They have also
observed a minimum value of conductivity for the sheets and an
unusual
form of the quantum Hall effect (Nature 438 197 and 201).




There is no such thing as rest mass. There is however rest energy of a
system of charges (not at rest wrt each other though). m_o = f/a, so
when either f or a equal zero, then m_o is undefined. But only when f
and a are equal zero is the particle at rest wrt an inertial frame.
Mass is meaningful only in the context of relative motion.

And BTW, I predicted that electrons are massless some time ago here,
their curved trajectories are only interpreted as products of inertia,
the rest mass being fictitious. Electrons move along geodesics in
curved space-time. If it works for gravitational fields, then it must
also work for electromagnetic fields. According to Weber, at least two
charges are required in a system in order to derive anything like *mass*.

The unusual form of the Hall effect is probably derivable from Weber's
premises as well.

You can reject my input if it suits you, and I'm sure you know that
I'm not especially dissuaded by so-called acceptable theory, but then
again this isn't the first physicsweb article that has supported my
radical arguments.

In the near future I expect you'll be posting news of electrons having
instantaneous speeds of c wrt each other. Already predicted as well :)

Richard Perry

If gravity is a Le Sage type phenom then it
takes considerably more than two members
to register a 'mass'.
John

Certainly. And this is true of other gravitational theories too, per Mach.
What I was implying was that what we call rest mass is an effect that
arises from the interaction of charges. It is proportional to but not
necessarily equal to, electromagnetic energy, per E=mc^2. This is why we
end up dimensionally with equations like m=kQ^2/r^2 for systems like the
positronium atom (classically). A single electron has no rest mass, or
should I say no intrinsic mass. All of the mass of the electron is
relativistic, i.e. fictitious, and corresponds to the energy stored in
its surrounding electromagnetic field. A moving charge has a stronger
field than a charge at rest, that is, one capable of doing more work
upon its deceleration with accompanying collapse of the field. Einstein
alluded to this in his speculations about inertia being electromagnetic
in origin.
Richard Perry
.
User: "Y.Porat"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 15 Nov 2005 01:47:39 AM
Please let me know when you stop playing chess
with your fellow parrots or even with yourself
there is some news for parrots and even for scientists:
'No mass - no real physics ''!
got it parrot???
just as simple as that may be too simple to digest. for 'sophisticated
people'
(what will they do with all the garbage they collected for so long
....?)
and if you what to boggle your balls to the rest of your life
and wast your un precious time - welcome.
ATB
Y.Porat
------------------------------
.




User: "Eric Gisse"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 10 Nov 2005 01:10:19 AM
Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

Two teams of physicists have discovered previously unseen exotic
behaviour in sheets of carbon atoms. The teams have shown that electrons
move through the sheets as if they have no rest mass. They have also
observed a minimum value of conductivity for the sheets and an unusual
form of the quantum Hall effect (Nature 438 197 and 201).

This is something I will have to look at the next time I have access to
Nature.
I don't understand how the electrons can behave as if they have no rest
mass, but I am sure Old Man or someone of similar knowledge has an
explanation.
.
User: "The Ghost In The Machine"

Title: Re: Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets 10 Nov 2005 09:00:04 AM
In sci.physics, Eric Gisse
<jowr.pi@gmail.com>
wrote
on 9 Nov 2005 23:10:19 -0800
<1131606619.067955.87990@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com>:


Sam Wormley wrote:

Electrons lose their mass in carbon sheets (Nov 9)
http://physicsweb.org/article/news/9/11/6

Two teams of physicists have discovered previously unseen exotic
behaviour in sheets of carbon atoms. The teams have shown that electrons
move through the sheets as if they have no rest mass. They have also
observed a minimum value of conductivity for the sheets and an unusual
form of the quantum Hall effect (Nature 438 197 and 201).


This is something I will have to look at the next time I have access to
Nature.

I don't understand how the electrons can behave as if they have no rest
mass, but I am sure Old Man or someone of similar knowledge has an
explanation.

I can make some guesses -- they'd probably be wrong, :-) but
in any event it's clear the electrons and the carbon atoms
are interacting.
I take it though that this is different from electron behavior
in metals.
Weird.
--
#191,

It's still legal to go .sigless.
.



  Page 1 of 1

1

 


Related Articles
 

NEWER

pg.1612     pg.1232     pg.940     pg.716     pg.544     pg.412     pg.311     pg.234     pg.175     pg.130     pg.96     pg.70     pg.50     pg.35     pg.24     pg.16     pg.10     pg.6     pg.3     pg.1

OLDER