Politics > Politics-USA > Former Undercover Intelligence Officers Blast Fred Thompson, Giuliani, Romney
| Topic: |
Politics > Politics-USA |
| User: |
"Harry Hope" |
| Date: |
15 Jun 2007 06:12:58 PM |
| Object: |
Former Undercover Intelligence Officers Blast Fred Thompson, Giuliani, Romney |
http://www.buzzflash.com/articles/alerts/259
Fri, 06/15/2007
A BUZZFLASH NEWS ALERT
Republican Presidential Candidates Betray the Rule of Law and Our
National Security According to Former Undercover Intelligence Officers
and Analysts
13 June 2007
The Honorable Mel Martinez
General Chairman
The Republican National Committee
310 First Street, SE
Washington, D.C. 20003
As former intelligence officers -- most of us have served the United
States in undercover positions -- we are saddened and appalled by the
recent public comments of former Senator Fred Thompson, former New
York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani, and former Governor Mitt Romney -- one
a potential candidate and the other two declared candidates for the
Republican nomination for president -- with respect to the perjury and
obstruction of justice conviction of Vice President Cheney's Chief of
Staff, Lewis "Scooter" Libby.
These men misrepresent the case against Mr. Libby and call into
question the integrity of a respected Federal Judge and U.S. attorney.
Their positions with respect to the just and fair punishment meted out
to Mr. Libby raise serious questions about their commitment to the
rule of law free of partisan bias.
We are particularly concerned by the recent speech by Fred Thompson,
who declared:
As you may recall, for some inexplicable reason, the CIA sent the
husband of one of its employees to Niger on a sensitive mission.
She had suggested it.
He came back to the U.S. and proceeded to publicly blast the
administration.
Naturally, everyone wanted to know "who is this guy?" and "why was he
sent to Niger?"
Just as naturally, the fact that he was married to Valerie Plame at
the CIA was leaked.
Having virtually guaranteed that Ms. Plame's identity would be
ultimately disclosed by using her, shall we say, "politically active"
husband, the CIA then demanded that this leak of her name be
investigated by the Justice Department for a possible violation of the
Intelligence Identities Protection Act.
The Justice Department, bowing to political and media pressure,
appointed a Special Counsel to investigate the leak and promised that
the Justice Department would exercise no supervision over him
whatsoever -- a status even the Attorney General does not have.
The only problem with this little scenario was that there was no
violation of the law, by anyone, and everybody -- the CIA, the Justice
Department and the Special Counsel knew it.
Ms. Plame was not a "covered person" under the statute and it was
obvious from the outset.
Furthermore, Justice and the Special Counsel knew who leaked Plame's
name and it wasn't Scooter Libby.
But the Beltway machinery was well oiled and geared up so the Special
Counsel spent the next two years moving heaven and earth to come up
with something, anything.
Finally he came up with some inconsistent recollections by Scooter
Libby, who had been up to his ears studying National Intelligence
Estimates.
But he worked for ***** Cheney, so that apparently was enough for the
special counsel.
First Things First (Fred Thompson/National Review)
http://article.nationalreview.com/print/?q=ZDA3ODFkNTA4NDM3YWYzMzc0NWQ1NjY4ZjhkZjkwNDI=
The factual errors in Mr. Thompson's statement are almost as egregious
as his partisan view that perjury and obstruction of justice are not
serious crimes.
For example, Thompson states that there is something implausible about
sending Ambassador Joseph Wilson to Niger to investigate reports that
Iraq was trying to buy yellow cake uranium.
In fact, Ambassador Wilson was uniquely qualified for the mission.
Having served as the acting Ambassador in Iraq and faced down Saddam
Hussein, Ambassador Wilson also was the Director of Africa in the
National Security Council and had served as an Ambassador in west
Africa and monitored the uranium mining activity of the country where
he was stationed.
Former Senator Thompson persists with the lie that there was no
"violation" of the Intelligence Identities Protection Act (IIPA).
But his claim is debunked by Federal Judge Reginald Walton and Federal
Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald, who, after reviewing the classified
personnel file of Valerie Plame Wilson, stated that she was in fact
covered by the IIPA when Robert Novak printed her name in July of
2003.
It also is important to correct the record that Valerie Wilson did not
suggest sending her husband to Niger.
She responded to an inquiry from her supervisor and provided a memo
laying out his capabilities.
The decision to send Ambassador Wilson to Niger was made by a senior
official in the Counter Proliferation Division of the CIA.
Fred Thompson also is factually wrong by claiming that Joe Wilson
returned from the trip, "and proceeded to publicly blast the
administration."
This is not true.
Ambassador Wilson made no public statements critical of the
Administration's claims about the alleged purchase of yellowcake
uranium until May of 2003 -- more than 15 months after returning from
the trip and only after the President made the specious claim in the
State of the Union address.
Our concern about Rudy Giuliani and Mitt Romney is narrower but
important -- are these men committed to a rule of law free of partisan
influence?
During the last Republican debate Rudy Giuliani said that: he'd have
to wait for the appeals process to play out to see if Libby met the
criteria for a pardon.
However, the former federal prosecutor said he believes the sentence
imposed on Libby was "way out of line."
Mr. Giuliani had a different standard for charges of perjury and
obstruction of justice on September 11, 1987:
The United States Attorney in Manhattan, Rudolph W. Giuliani, declared
yesterday that the one-year prison sentence that a Queens judge
received for perjury was "somewhat shocking."
"A sentence of one year seemed to me to be very lenient," Mr. Giuliani
said, when asked to comment on the sentence imposed Wednesday on
Justice Francis X. Smith, the former
Queens administrative judge. . . .
Justice Smith was convicted of committing perjury before a grand jury
investigating corruption in the city, Mr. Giuliani said later, adding
that "he could have helped root out corruption" by cooperating with
the grand jury.
Mr. Romney's statement is more outrageous.
He accused Patrick Fitzgerald of abusing "prosecutorial discretion."
The case against Mr. Libby is straightforward.
He blocked the efforts of Federal agents to investigate the leak of
the identity of an undercover CIA officer who was covered by the
Intelligence Identities Protection Act.
Mr. Libby lied to Federal law enforcement officials investigating the
leak.
Most importantly, Mr. Libby was convicted in a fair trial of perjury
and obstruction of justice.
This is not an issue of Republican versus Democrat.
The signatories of this letter include registered Republicans,
Democrats, and Independents.
We believe that Republicans and Democrats alike must commit themselves
to upholding the rule of law and refusing to use clandestine CIA
officers as a political football.
In this regard we find that the recent comments by Fred Thompson, Rudy
Giuliani and Mitt Romney [are] sadly wanting and unworthy of the
highest elected office in the United States.
We are pleased, however, that the Republican Party is offering
candidates who do believe in the rule of law.
Former Virginia Governor Jim Gilmore and U.S. Congressman Ron Paul
spoke boldly and reaffirmed the commitment of Republicans to uphold
the rule of law.
Both emphasized that the law must be applied to Mr. Libby, regardless
of his social standing or wealth.
We believe that Governor Gilmore and Congressman Paul reflect the
values espoused by Ronald Reagan.
Good intelligence should not be a partisan issue.
It is a professional obligation of intelligence officers to provide
politicians with the best information and their best judgment.
And it is the professional obligation of politicians to uphold the
rule of law and ensure that the Constitution of the United States is
upheld and enforced.
On this critical issue we believe that the statements by Fred
Thompson, Rudy Giuliani and Mitt Romney do damage to the reputation of
the Republican Party and undermine public respect for the judicial
system.
Respectfully yours,
Ray Close, Directorate of Operations
James Marcinkowski, Directorate of Operations
Philip Giraldi, Directorate of Operations
Michael Grimaldi, Directorate of Intelligence
Ray McGovern, Directorate of Intelligence
Melvin Goodman, Directorate of Intelligence
Larry Johnson, Directorate of Intelligence
David MacMichael, National Intelligence Council
________________________________________________
Harry
.
|
|
|
Related Articles |
|
|
