Politics > Politics-USA > Why Aid To Africa And Impoverished States Anywhere Is Futile, Even Counterproductive
| Topic: |
Politics > Politics-USA |
| User: |
"Impervious" |
| Date: |
22 Dec 2005 05:43:14 PM |
| Object: |
Why Aid To Africa And Impoverished States Anywhere Is Futile, Even Counterproductive |
Today guilt-ridden, foolish celebrities in Hollywood and elsewhere are
sickening in
their mawkish, pious and sanctimonious concern for the world's impoverished
nations and
suffering populations.And these leftist do-gooders are too ignorant
to be aware of Ludwig von Mises dictum that "It's
either capitalism or chaos for any nation and for world civilization.
In 1994 about one million people in Rwanda were murdered and butchered when
a brigade of well-trained and equipped troops could have prevented this
genocide.
But no one in the West did anything. At the time, Democrat Bill Clinton was
U.S. president,
Liberal Jean Chrétien was Canada's PM and the callous UN was living the good
life in New York City.
Now we have a whole host of celebrities who are going to "save" the world's
poor
with still more of other people's money. But it will not work. The great
free-market economist Lord Peter Bauer,
who has been marginalized, like F.A. Hayek, for his un-socialist, political
un-correctness,
noted how aid handouts to Third World nations were almost invariably
counter-productive.
"Such aid fed corruption and it tended to get the growth process upside
down concentrating on
large-scale infrastructure while ignoring the importance of sound markets,
private property rights
the rule of law and small enterprise". (Peter Foster, "Bono's and Bill
[Gates'] hands in our pockets).
"And yet such warnings are perpetually buried beneath the naive
redistributionism that arrives
with every new generation of do-gooders, and which is particularly popular
with the more cynical
professional redistributors and opportunists who populate governments, the
UN and other international agencies.
.
|
|
| User: "pcourterelle" |
|
| Title: Re: Why Aid To Africa And Impoverished States Anywhere Is Futile, Even Counterproductive |
23 Dec 2005 02:46:32 AM |
|
|
"Impervious" <impervious@sympatico.ca> wrote in message
news:nSGqf.2419$1Y4.270034@news20.bellglobal.com...
Today guilt-ridden, foolish celebrities in Hollywood and elsewhere are
sickening in
their mawkish, pious and sanctimonious concern for the world's
impoverished nations and
suffering populations.And these leftist do-gooders are too ignorant
to be aware of Ludwig von Mises dictum that "It's
either capitalism or chaos for any nation and for world civilization.
At minimum they got you thinking and writing about it. So they succeeded to
the degree they could.
pc
.
|
|
|
|
| User: "Stan Pierce" |
|
| Title: Re: Why Aid To Africa And Impoverished States Anywhere Is Futile, Even Counterproductive |
22 Dec 2005 10:14:27 PM |
|
|
"Impervious" <impervious@sympatico.ca> wrote in message
news:nSGqf.2419$1Y4.270034@news20.bellglobal.com...
Today guilt-ridden, foolish celebrities in Hollywood and elsewhere are
sickening in
their mawkish, pious and sanctimonious concern for the world's impoverished
nations and
suffering populations.And these leftist do-gooders are too ignorant
to be aware of Ludwig von Mises dictum that "It's
either capitalism or chaos for any nation and for world civilization.
In 1994 about one million people in Rwanda were murdered and butchered when
a brigade of well-trained and equipped troops could have prevented this
genocide.
But no one in the West did anything. At the time, Democrat Bill Clinton was
U.S. president,
Liberal Jean Chrétien was Canada's PM and the callous UN was living the good
life in New York City.
Now we have a whole host of celebrities who are going to "save" the world's
poor
with still more of other people's money. But it will not work. The great
free-market economist Lord Peter Bauer,
who has been marginalized, like F.A. Hayek, for his un-socialist, political
un-correctness,
noted how aid handouts to Third World nations were almost invariably
counter-productive.
"Such aid fed corruption and it tended to get the growth process upside down
concentrating on
large-scale infrastructure while ignoring the importance of sound markets,
private property rights
the rule of law and small enterprise". (Peter Foster, "Bono's and Bill
[Gates'] hands in our pockets).
"And yet such warnings are perpetually buried beneath the naive
redistributionism that arrives
with every new generation of do-gooders, and which is particularly popular
with the more cynical
professional redistributors and opportunists who populate governments, the UN
and other international agencies.
I remember when Oxfam started 40 odd years ago and they published a photo the
frail sad sorry face of a starving Ibo child in Nigeria. They pulled in
millions of pounds out of sympathy. Then of course that kid probably survived
to grow up to machete to death his tribal enemy. The sad fact of Africa since
the white man left. Nothing can be done for them.
.
|
|
|
| User: "John Therault" |
|
| Title: Re: Why Aid To Africa And Impoverished States Anywhere Is Futile, Even Counterproductive |
22 Dec 2005 10:29:51 PM |
|
|
Stan Pierce wrote:
I remember when Oxfam started 40 odd years ago and they published a photo
the frail sad sorry face of a starving Ibo child in Nigeria. They pulled
in millions of pounds out of sympathy. Then of course that kid probably
survived to grow up to machete to death his tribal enemy. The sad fact
of Africa since the white man left. Nothing can be done for them.
I prefer the old way.
If you leave people in need, there's a good chance that they'll steal it from
you later on.
Viva Idi Amim!
It kind of reminds me of the old band called the Battered Wives - Uganda
Stomp!
Bomp de la Bomp!
***** the poor!
.
|
|
|
|
|

|
Related Articles |
|
|