December 9, 2002



BY WAY OF DECEPTION
Israel pulls a fast one - and gets caught



The Israelis are riding high, these days - but not, perhaps, for long.
Ever since 9/11, the Israeli government and its American amen corner
have been making the point that Israel's fight is now America's fight,
and this argument has met with some success. A recent article in
Ha'aretz notes that Israel is winning the struggle for American hearts
and minds:

"The conventional wisdom among policy-makers in Israel and the United
States is that if there is one front on which Israel enjoys a clear
advantage in the international arena, it is hasbara - information and
public relations in the United States."

Congress is practically Israeli-occupied territory, and the Bushies
are in their back pocket: however, there are still some elements of
the American public who have not been brought to heel, and this, we
are told, shows that "Israel has cause for concern."

It seems that only half of the "influentials" - professionals in the
media, politics, and academia, and others who regularly follow the
news - take the Israel-can-do-no-wrong line. The Israelis and their
American supporters find this worrisome, as well they should. In spite
of a constant drumbeat of pro-Israel propaganda, a well-organized
cadre of American boosters, and the slavish support of our government,
still a great many Americans are able to think clearly and critically
about our troublesome "ally." As Ha'aretz puts it: "

"For every individual that supports Israel, there is another who
opposes it. This is happening at time when the Palestinians are at a
disadvantage in public relations, when the president has openly
declared his support for Israel and Israel's political lobby is at its
height."

Those numbers are bound to get worse as news of the latest Israeli
caper hits the headlines. It really wasn't such a hot idea for the
Mossad to recruit Palestinians into a phony Al Qaeda cell in Gaza. It
was too easy to trace the cell-phone calls and emails back to Israel,
as well as Germany and Lebanon. Aside from that, however, there was
something a little fishy about their recruitment methods, such as this
message cited by ABC News (via Reuters):

"After receiving reports from your brothers in the area about your
good morals and Islamic beliefs...we appeal to you to work within the
ranks of the mujahideen (Muslim fighters) and we will support you with
money and weapons. Call us at this number...and identify yourself as
Abu Anas. The telephone call should be made between three and five in
the afternoon... After you read the letter and understand its content,
burn it.

"(Signed), Your brother and humble slave of God, Osama bin Laden."

Recruits to this faux-Al Qaeda were given weapons (most of them didn't
work) and money provided by "Palestinian collaborators with Israel,"
three of whom are in a Palestinian jail. According to PLO "preventive
security" chief Rashid Abu Shbak, some of the money "was transferred
from bank accounts in Jerusalem or Israel."

These revelations come in the wake of Israeli Prime Minister Ariel
Sharon's claim that Al Qaeda is behind recent attacks on Israel, and
is present in the occupied territories and Lebanon. A phony "Al Qaeda"
website has been set up, which we are supposed to believe is the voice
of the Evil One in cyberspace: its recent pronouncement that a
Palestinian "branch" of Al Qaeda has been formed was duly reported by
the Washington Post, which also transcribed the lamentation of one
Rachel Bronson, director of Middle East Studies at the Council on
Foreign Relations:

"'The idea that al Qaeda is establishing a special cell to focus on
Israelis is horrifying news.' ... Al Qaeda's role could be extremely
destabilizing, she added, because 'it will be weighing in on the side
of Hamas,' the Palestinian Islamic group that launches suicide
bombings against Israeli civilians and has been deemed a terrorist
organization by the U.S. government."

What is horrifying is that anyone takes such thinly-disguised
disinformation seriously. Repeating such nonsense with a straight face
is, one imagines, what makes Ms. Bronson so well-qualified for her
job.

Israel's great achievement in the political and diplomatic realm has
been to draw the unleashed anger of the American giant away from the
perpetrators of 9/11 and toward its own enemies: Saddam Hussein,
Hamas, and the fictitious "Islamic Al-Qaeda of Palestine," which
exists only "by way of deception," to borrow a phrase from the
official motto of the Mossad.

"By way of deception, thou shalt do war" - a principle the Israelis
have always lived up to. Juxtaposed against the mounting evidence - a
recent series of reports in the German and British media depict Mossad
agents in the U.S. living "next door to Mohammed Atta" - the exposure
of this "false flag" operation draws the curtain on the terrorist
enigma. This demonstrates that an Israeli connection to the worst
terrorist atrocity in our history is not an "urban myth," as one
Justice Department spokesperson put it, but a sinister and
increasingly likely possibility.

In all the columns I've written on this subject, my thesis has been
limited in scope. I've said only that the Israelis had a certain
amount of foreknowledge - to what degree is not known - and failed to
warn us. Not that they were behind 9/11. Nor am I saying that now. But
I have a question: If the Israelis are running phony "Al Qaeda" cells
in Palestine and Lebanon, why not in South Florida, or New York?

This question, you can be sure, won't be asked by the Kissinger
Commission, as the "National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the
United States" will inevitably be called, and yet surely - given the
way in which 9/11 changed our lives - it is one worth raising. Which
brings us to the reason I'm taking most of this week off..

Well, not really "off" - I'll be working harder than ever,
unfortunately, trying to get the first draft my new book in shape. The
Terror Enigma: Israel and the 9/11 Connection will be published next
year by Verso Books. The book lays out the evidence that Israeli
intelligence not only shadowed the hijackers, but also succeeded in
diverting the American authorities away from the plotters' trail. They
launched a massive covert action aimed at government facilities in the
U.S. - the infamous "art students."

"By way of deception, thou shalt do war" - a war for survival, as the
Israelis see it, that must be waged against the West as well as the
Muslim world. As long as Americans see the "war on terrorism" as the
two-sided Manichean struggle described by George W. Bush - "you're
either with us, or with the terrorists" - their anger and frustration
can be mobilized in support of an all-out war on the Arab nations. But
if Israel had some foreknowledge - or even a connection with - Al
Qaeda in America, and not just the Palestinian "branch," then American
rage will be directed at
another target.


Andrew Sullivan is outraged that opponents of the Iraq war are putting
the "war on terrorism" in ironic quotes, and has initiated one of his
tiresome campaigns to have it stamped out:

"QUOTATION MARK WATCH: Have you begun to notice how some commentators
(mainly on the left but also on the paleo-right) have begun to put the
term 'war on terrorism' in quote marks? I wonder what part of the
phrase they don't buy. That we are fighting terrorism?"

You got that right, Andy. Surely there is a dangerous sort of irony in
the act of declaring a war, and then failing to see one of your
opponents. It is a danger that patriots cannot fail to point out.
Until Americans, particularly those in government, stop seeing the
world with blinders on, the ironic quotes stay.

At any rate, as much as I dislike abandoning my readers for even a
day, I'll be gone for the rest of the week, and back on my regular
schedule starting next Monday: unless, of course, the shooting starts
before then ..

- Justin Raimondo

comments on this article?
send them to backtalk!
[visit backtalk!]


Please Support Antiwar.com

Antiwar.com
520 S. Murphy Avenue, #202
Sunnyvale, CA 94086


or Contribute Via our Secure Server
Credit Card Donation Form


Your contributions are now tax-deductible







Antiwar.com Home Page

Most recent column by Justin Raimondo


Archived columns

By Way of Deception
12/9/02

Portrait of a War Bird
12/6/02

To Russia, With Love
12/4/02

Hail Henry!
12/2/02

Fighting Dirty
11/29/02

War Party Dumps Bush?
11/27/02

Sabotage!
11/25/02

Totally Clueless
11/22/02

War Party Stalled
11/20/02

Debunking the Myth of 9/11
11/18/02

Liberal Imperialism
11/15/02

He's Alive!
11/13/02

Jonah Goldberg, Bottom Feeder
11/11/02

A Mandate for War?
11/8/02

Team Killers
11/6/02

Attack of the Oxymorons
11/4/02

Neocons of the Left
11/1/02

Warmongers, Left and Right
10/30/02

I Ain't Marchin' Anymore
10/28/02

A Man Named Muhammad
10/25/02

Patriots For Peace
10/23/02

Smearing the Antiwar Movement
10/21/02

North Korea's Halloween Surprise
10/18/02

The Sniper
10/16/02

The Two Faces of Ronald Radosh
10/14/02

Iraq - First Stop on the Road to Empire
10/11/02

Larry Ellison's Golden Age: Profiteers of the Warfare State
10/9/02

Call Congress!
10/7/02

9/11: What Did Israel Know?
10/4/02

Why Jim McDermott Is a Hero
10/2/02

Previous columns

Justin Raimondo is the editorial director of Antiwar.com. He is also
the author of Reclaiming the American Right: The Lost Legacy of the
Conservative Movement (with an Introduction by Patrick J. Buchanan),
(1993), and Into the Bosnian Quagmire: The Case Against U.S.
Intervention in the Balkans (1996). He is an Adjunct Scholar with the
Ludwig von Mises Institute, in Auburn, Alabama, a Senior Fellow at the
Center for Libertarian Studies, and writes frequently for Chronicles:
A Magazine of American Culture. He is the author of An Enemy of the
State: The Life of Murray N. Rothbard.